Image of the day

From the
ATWB Customer Gallery

North American & Pelican Nebulae

About Astromart

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Best Low-Power 2" EP's for 2" BV are...?

Started by Hootscoot, 12/05/2009 01:39PM
Post Reply
Posted 12/05/2009 01:39PM | Edited 12/05/2009 01:40PM Opening Post
John Levine
View public profile Send a private message to John Levine Find more posts by John Levine Find threads started by John Levine
Forum Member
Hootscoot's avatar

Join Date: Dec 2001

Location: Wabash IN, US

Posts: 16

For Siebert Elite 45 BV, I have a pair of 22mm Nagler type 4's.
Recommendations for a low-power pair: good build quality, eye relief that is not excessive; relatively affordable, works with an IPD of 65mm; field stop that can make use of the larger format BV; not too heavy.
I have found that these criteria narrow the field of contenders pretty quickly.
Short of loading up with Multimags and sticking with the Naglers, what are my options?
At first blush, it looks like the Baader-hyperion Aspherics, either 36mm or 30mm may hit that "sweet spot", but I will defer to the expertise of the more experienced participants of this Forum.
Thanks! smile
Quote
JMI NGT-18 f/10 GoTo Reflector, "Magellan"
C11 f/10 CFT XLT Fastar, "Dave"
CotoSKY 8.25" f/6 Achromat, "Blackjack"
Meade AR6 f/8 Achromat, "Kalliopi"
WO FLT 110 f/7 Apo, "Apollo"
Coronado PST f/10 "Icarus"
Canon IS 15 X 50 Binoculars
Losmandy G11/Gemini4
Discmounts DM-6, Sky Commander, StarBeam
Denk II Universal Power X Switch Binoviewer
Mallincam HPC/Watek monitor
Collins I3/Astronomik H-a/Starsweeper
Celestron SkyScout
...and some nice glass.
Posted 12/05/2009 03:41PM #1
Donald Durbin
View public profile Send a private message to Donald Durbin Find more posts by Donald Durbin Find threads started by Donald Durbin
Forum Member
DonDurbin's avatar

Join Date: Nov 2002

Location: Tallahassee FL, US

Posts: 244

For Siebert 45mm Elites, I always found that the best EP's were the Siebert 2" 36mm Observatory EP's.

Don Durbin
Quote
Posted 09/05/2018 12:02AM #2
Peter Glus
View public profile Send a private message to Peter Glus Find more posts by Peter Glus Find threads started by Peter Glus
Forum Member

Join Date: Feb 2006

Location: Jackson Heights NY, US

Posts: 183

Ive been thinking about the same problem, as I just got a 45mm Seibert.  I have his EPs, but was thinking about the 22nag and for low power the new maysuyama 32 degrees.  I read the center 70 is great and while the outer edge is soft I think thats just a framing effect for me.  The KK Widescan IIs are an option, but hard to piece together.  Also, the older Axioms would be nice too...I will try to assemble a set eventually.
Quote
Posted 11/10/2021 04:51AM #3
Peter Glus
View public profile Send a private message to Peter Glus Find more posts by Peter Glus Find threads started by Peter Glus
Forum Member

Join Date: Feb 2006

Location: Jackson Heights NY, US

Posts: 183

I have used the Black Nights for a few years.  My thoughts:

Harry S's EPs are really good.  I have the 17, 24, and 36mm EPs he sells.  I also have a 2x barlow that fits in the end.  The 36 is a wonderful EP...all of them are quite nice.  

I am currently gathering a pair of 34mm Old Style Axioms...dont ask me why...memories

I tried two Matsuyama 32mm EPs...they were really heavy but of course the views were outrageous

I tried two Nag 22 T 4s...very very nice

All in all, I generally stick with Harry's EPs.  There are fewer elements, they are light, and the center is great for contrast.  

I am using this in a 16" LX200.

 
Quote
Posted 11/10/2021 11:30AM #4
John Levine
View public profile Send a private message to John Levine Find more posts by John Levine Find threads started by John Levine
Forum Member
Hootscoot's avatar

Join Date: Dec 2001

Location: Wabash IN, US

Posts: 16

Originally Posted by Peter Glus
I have used the Black Nights for a few years.  My thoughts:

Harry S's EPs are really good.  I have the 17, 24, and 36mm EPs he sells.  I also have a 2x barlow that fits in the end.  The 36 is a wonderful EP...all of them are quite nice.  

I am currently gathering a pair of 34mm Old Style Axioms...dont ask me why...memories

I tried two Matsuyama 32mm EPs...they were really heavy but of course the views were outrageous

I tried two Nag 22 T 4s...very very nice

All in all, I generally stick with Harry's EPs.  There are fewer elements, they are light, and the center is great for contrast.  

I am using this in a 16" LX200.


Peter,

Appreciate your thoughts and perspectives!
Work has kept me out of the loop for some time now, so living vicariously through the experiences of others.
The 16" Meade was always the Holy Grail for me back in the day. May yours bring you joy for years to come.
CS,
-J

 
Quote
JMI NGT-18 f/10 GoTo Reflector, "Magellan"
C11 f/10 CFT XLT Fastar, "Dave"
CotoSKY 8.25" f/6 Achromat, "Blackjack"
Meade AR6 f/8 Achromat, "Kalliopi"
WO FLT 110 f/7 Apo, "Apollo"
Coronado PST f/10 "Icarus"
Canon IS 15 X 50 Binoculars
Losmandy G11/Gemini4
Discmounts DM-6, Sky Commander, StarBeam
Denk II Universal Power X Switch Binoviewer
Mallincam HPC/Watek monitor
Collins I3/Astronomik H-a/Starsweeper
Celestron SkyScout
...and some nice glass.
Post Reply

Funding Member

Telescopes, Astronomy, Binoculars

Sponsors


View all sponsors

Search