Image of the day

Captured by
Larry Hubble

Markarian's Chain

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

New light on Mars methane mystery

Started by kmichaelm, 01/15/2009 07:04PM
Posted 01/15/2009 07:04PM Opening Post
New light on Mars methane mystery

Large quantities of methane gas have been detected on Mars, Nasa scientists have announced in Science journal.

The gas could be produced either by geological activity or by life.

Methane was detected in the Martian atmosphere five years ago; scientists have found it is more abundant over particular parts of the planet.

It should last for only a short time in the atmosphere until it is destroyed by sunlight, and so its continued presence means it is being replenished.

This suggests the methane is made by an ongoing process.

But the ultimate origin of the methane could either be an ancient or a modern one, say the researchers.

"The fact that we have found three discrete regions where Mars is releasing methane at this time means we have a window into processes occurring under the surface of the planet," said co-author Michael Mumma, a senior planetary scientist at Nasa's Goddard Spaceflight Center in Maryland, US.

"The production (of methane) is likely due to only one of two possibilities. The first is geochemistry, the second is biology. That raises much interest on which one is the dominant production mechanism."

If the methane is produced by geological activity, it could either originate from active Martian volcanoes or from a process called serpentinisation.

The latter process occurs at low temperatures and occurs when rocks rich in the minerals olivine and pyroxene react chemically with water, releasing methane.

Seasonal release

"It could be occurring on Mars. In that case, we might expect the methane to be released only under regions that are volcanic districts," said Dr Mumma.

"On the other hand, there could be biology that's going on either very near the surface or deep below the permafrost layer. Then in order to release captured gases to the atmosphere one needs to access those sub-permafrost regions."

Some scientists consider it possible that microbes could have survived for aeons below the Martian permafrost layer, where water changes from ice into liquid.
In deep canyons, or the walls of yawning craters, ice might plug fissures or pores connecting these sub-permafrost regions to the atmosphere.

But the ice could disappear during spring and summer, Dr Mumma speculated.

The team used a technique called infrared spectroscopy at three different Earth-based telescopes to monitor about 90% of the planet's surface for seven years (equivalent to three Martian years).

They identified "plumes" of methane on Mars during 2003; at one point in their study, the primary plume of methane contained an estimated 19,000 tonnes of the gas.

Future exploration

This implies the gas was released from discrete regions on the planet. However, these regions do not move the researchers significantly towards one theory of methane production more than another.

"We've demonstrated there are regions of active (methane) release," said Dr Mumma.

"What we'd really like to do is map the entire planet identifying all such regions of release and validating that some are reproducible from year to year.

"In addition, we'd like to map the gases being released to establish which of those are more likely biological in origin versus others that may be geochemical in origin.

"On this basis we could target several interesting sites for lander missions."

Andrew Coates, from the Mullard Space Science Laboratory in Surrey, UK, said: "The observation of short-lived, seasonally varying clouds of methane from specific regions on Mars is a tantalising result. It shows there must be an underground source, past or present."

Dr Coates, who is not involved with the latest research, added: "Seasonal effects may open up fissures to allow increased escape into the atmosphere. But this could be a sign of either geology or biology.

"Both are exciting; we will not be sure which it is until we can analyse the methane in-situ at the surface."

Nasa's Mars Science Laboratory (MSL) rover, due to launch to the Red Planet in 2011, will carry instruments that have the potential to distinguish between carbon in gases produced by biological activity and those with a geochemical origin.

Story from BBC NEWS:

Published: 2009/01/15 19:01:21 GMT

Posted 01/16/2009 04:51AM #1
Maybe it was a good ol Chilli cookoff. 8)

Thanks kMM for sharing.



Be a Blessing too someone today !
Clear Skys,
Bill - Astro Hillbilly 8)
And Pluto is still a Planet !
Posted 01/16/2009 12:28PM #2
Like any large organization I bet there is a large diversity of opinion on this subject inside NASA.

They put their game face on for the press conference and came out hedging but I bet there were some really intense "discussions" that went on before hand with some highly qualified people absolutely convinced that the methane is biological in nature.

We shall see how this evolves...pun intended.


"Don't sweat the petty things and don't pet the sweaty things" 8O
Posted 01/18/2009 02:06PM #3
What seems to be missing in all the discussions on Mars' surface features, methane, etc., is the possibility that Mars may have been a methane planet at one time. The mania to prove that life exists on Mars masks other plausible explanations of surface features, etc. It would not be surprising that Mars has some water, but to propose that oceans existed boggles my mind unless Mars was once much closer to the sun. We merely need to take a look at the earth's history to see the problems of some of the proposals on Mars' climatic history.

Can someone direct me to a credible study that considers Mars as a possible methane planet?


I Yam What I Yam!