Ok- I give up on cylindrical finders....
A couple of months back on ebay, I saw an ad for an old ATM-made Newtonian scope that had the finder on the INSIDE of the main tube. I couldn't see from the pictures how it was supposed to be looked into- whether it had its own eyepiece or somehow interacted with the main focuser (I guess with a variant of a flip mirror?).
Obviously it was a narrow aperture finder, since anything else would start getting in the way of the objective mirror. But it got me thinking that perhaps one could mound a finder on the upper side of the secondary. Someone must have thought of this before, and perhaps posted it here? This in-line finder could have an aperture as broad as the narrow axis of the secondary.
If it were just piggybacked it would still need its own eyepiece and focuser, and if it were to feed into the main focuser, then one would still need to be able to flip or turn the secondary. Or I suppose one could use a combination sled and regular in/out focuser with a secondary-piggybacked finder?
Thoughts?
Thanks again for your indulgence.
Jess Tauber
[email protected]