Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

bino dilemma

Started by potterrb, 05/21/2004 01:33PM
Posted 05/21/2004 01:33PM Opening Post
I have a dilemma, and need some sound advice.

I own a pair of the Canon 15x50 IS binocs, and really love them. The
IS works great, and the optics are also fantastic. They are threaded
on the front, so I have UV haze filters to protect the glass when not
in use and for daytime viewing, and thread on solar filters. I also
can get 58mm-48mm step down rings for using standard 2" filters.

However, I find that even with IS their hefty weight makes them hard
to use for long without a mount. I finally decided to sell the
Canons to finance the purchase of a pair of Adlerblick 7x50s for
widefield handheld viewing, and a pair of Oberwerk 22x100s for
mounted viewing (and 4x the light grasp). The problem is that every
time I go to post my Canon 15x50s on Astromart, I find that I can't
bring myself to do it!

Am I doing the right thing? It seems logically correct, but I am
having trouble parting with the Canons.

Thanks,
Brian
Posted 05/21/2004 10:44PM | Edited 05/21/2004 10:45PM #1
I'd go with Jim's put and keep the IS and buy the other two as well. If you find the IS's sitting on the shelf all the time, then sell them.

I just got a pair of previously owned Canon IS 12x36 (not the II's) from a right nice fellow here on Astromart (sorry, JimR, first time I ignored your advice wink. First impressions: The hold the button down requirement is less than desirable (this is not an issue on the newer ones). The weight is 2.1 lbs, which is tolerable but not what I would classify as lightweight. They are not as "get out of the way of the view" comfortable as the Pentax PCF 7x and 10x 50's I tried. Where are the end caps? Seems silly to have a pair of $600 binoculars without some sort of protection available outside the case.

Ok, enough negatives. I always get those out of the way first, especially if I really like something.

The amount of detail I have been able to see on terrestrial targets (especially my fuzzy dog's head) is significantly increased with IS on vs off. With IS off, I noticed the phenomenon where the eye is chasing the ant on the flag at 30 yds and it is extremely difficult to count legs or make out the feelers. Push the magic button, though and the ant clearly has 6 legs and 1 feeler (must have had a tragic leaf blower incident). The dog's ears needed cleaning, BTW.

Anyway, these 12x36 IS's can stay for a while. At least until I can give them a go at night. I suspect that I will be pleased.

So, keep your IS's. They seem to be all that.

Clear skies,

Tom
Posted 05/22/2004 02:14AM #2
Hi Brian,

I feel exactly the same way about my 18x50's. Since I use mine mounted most of the time anyway, by all rights I should sell them and get a pair of good 70's. But they're hard to part with (one never knows when the IS will come in handy, he rationalizes...)

If you can swing it, I would suggest picking up the 100's first while keeping the Canons. The 100's are much bigger and heavier and there will be times you won't be able to take them or will just want that quick look the Canons are perfect for.

I hardly ever use my 7x50's for astronomy.

Good Luck,
Milt