Image of the day

Captured by
Arthur Hogan

Wizard Nebula

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Canon IS binos

Started by ivanong, 01/14/2004 12:48PM
Posted 01/14/2004 12:48PM Opening Post
Hi All:
I am thinking about buying a pair of IS 15x50 binos because I like the hand-held aspect of these binos.
I have to wear eye glasses when observing because of astigmatism- anyoone with some thoughts/experience about this? IS the eye relief ok? I have thin-type eye glass lens. Also, overall impression-wise, do you like your pair?
Thanks, Ivan
Posted 01/15/2004 01:34AM #1
Hi Ivan,

I have owned the Canon 18x50IS for 2-1/2 years.

Regarding eye relief, I do not wear eye glasses when I observe but I checked my owner's manual and both the 15x and 18x are spec'd at 15mm. This may not be enough. However, if you already have a telescope and can use EP's with 15mm eye relief, then it would probably be OK with the eye cups folded back.

The bigger issue on these binoculars is whether the image stabilization is really worth the added cost. Because the contrast and image quality are quite good, I have been pushing my 18x50's pretty deep, and have come to believe that the cost of IS would have been better put into larger apertures (assuming the image quality was maintained).

I say this because I have not even turned on my IS since I acquired the Manfrotto 3011BN tripod and 3130 micro fluid head that Erik Lin and Ed Zarenski recommended on this forum. Yes, after spending all the extra $$ for IS, I ended up mounting them anyway.

AS you probably know, serious observing often involves finding objects that can only be located with the help of star charts. IS does not help you regain the exact same area of sky after you have consulted a star chart - only mounting will do that. Furthermore, as good as the IS is, for studying an object in detail it is not steady enough. For example, I have split alpha Delphini (9.6") mounted, but cannot do it using the IS.

For a non-IS, high image quality, larger aperture alternative in this price range you might consider the Fujinon 16x70. I don't know what the eye relief is, but someone else will. Or you could go for lower cost binos and put the difference into a good mount. There will be many others with good ideas on this forum.

Good Luck, Milt

Posted 01/15/2004 05:40PM #2
Ivan,
The Canon 15x50IS works as advertised. Optical quality is outstanding. The only negative I can think of is that for extended viewing of an object, these binocs start to get heavy. Even with good image stabilization (and Canon's is very good), you still have to support weight of the binocs. This is not a problem for quick looks. But studying an object for an extended period will put a strain on you arms. One solution is to use a reclining beach chair and rest your elbows on arms of chair...and let your head support weight of binocs. It's not elegant but it works. You can also simply lay on ground and achieve the same thing. A mount is nice, but of course this compromises portability.
Rob Mackie
Posted 01/15/2004 07:44PM #3
hi Ivan,
I had the 15X50 IS binos for about a year, after which I sold them. I bought them after having read the reviews in S&T, as well as the reviews on the Todd Gross' web site. They do work as advertised, but in terms of optical performance, I found that they left a little something to be desired. The S&T review alluded to this. They're not up to the same standards (in terms of optical imaging quality) as high-end Nikons or other top-quality binos. I've compared them with the Nikon Astroluxe and Prostar binos, as well as the 10X42 SE, and the Miyauchi 20X77's, all of which I own (or have owned), and the Canon's aren't quite as good on star tests. Star images aren't quite pinpoint, and they have flaring around bright objects such as the moon and planets. For terrestrial/nature viewing however, they're very good, and they're outstanding when used while boating, or on an ocean cruise, as I had the ocasion to do.
-andy z
Posted 01/15/2004 11:00PM #4
Rob Mackie describes very well how the Canon IS binos can be used. I have the 15x50 and 10x30. They are both excellent binoculars. I think the image stabilization is incredible. When handheld, you can see so much more in daytime or nighttime.

Both binos are very sharp to the edge and have excellent contrast. Color on the edge of the moon is quite noticable however. I think performance can vary a bit between these binoculars though. I had to exchange my 15x50 twice before I got one that I was happy with. No flare on these. The difference in quality might just had been a coincidence at the time I made the purchase.

I have compared the Canon 15x50 to my ProOptic 11x70 handheld and can tell you that I much rather use the Canon. They show more contrast and I can see a lot more using the IS. Even with the 11x70 mounted, I like the views of the handheld Canon more. The only thing about the 15x50 IS is that they will become heavy when handheld unless you can lay on a chair/floor like Rob mentioned. The 10x30s don't have this issue.

The 10x30 IS are in my opinion the best binos for their size. They are very light/portable and are excellent in daylight and perform very well (for their size) at night. Images are razor sharp. When looking through the 10x30s at night with IS turned on, you would think you're looking through bigger binos.

The great thing about these binos is portability w/o having to use a mount. You can be out watching in a few seconds. They do consume power quickly so you would want a few rechargable batteries. Eye relief is also a bit tight on the 15x50 IS. I don't like the way they designed the eyecups either. Once you press the IS button you won't want to go back...

-Pablo