Limiting magnitudes

Started by light trap, 08/09/2003 08:42AM
Posted 08/09/2003 08:42AM Opening Post
Here's a little calculator for figuring limiting magnitude under different conditions with different size telescopes. Put in refractor for binoculars and convert objective size to inches by dividing by 2.5
http://www.go.ednet.ns.ca/~larry/astro/maglimit.html

It's fun to play around with that calculator, but I'm not sure that I really trust it's output entirely. For instance, I wanted to see how things would deteriorate as I aged, so I entered values for 20x80 binoculars, mag 5.5 skies, refractor, intermediate skill level etc. and then only changed the age variable by adding 5 years over the course of several decades. It actually had the limiting magnitude *increasing* with increased age. In fact, it had a 15yr old intermediate skill level seeing less than a 55yr old intermediate skill level. I repeated that with 20x100, 25x100 and 40x100 optics and watched what it computed. It claims 11.83 for 25x100 & 12.45 for 40x100 at mag. 5.5 skies, 35* from zenith. I think that's optimistic, at best.

As far as figuring out what seeing condition limiting magnitude to enter, here are a couple sites. Neither is particularly great.
North American Meteor Network:
http://www.namnmeteors.org/lm_calc.html

SEDS:
http://www.seds.org/billa/lm/rjm.html

Those can sugest areas of the sky to look at to see what you can see. I don't really like the fact that the SEDS one has areas defined by triangles. It's kind of tough to visualize the triangles artificially drawn beside a constellation to count stars held within. If you type "limiting magnitude" or "telescope limiting magnitude" into Google or Dogpile it's kind of amusing seeing what all comes back. Of course, the fact that I find it amusing may have more to do with the fact that it's 4:30am and I have NO sky to look at,(again), so I'm stuck with computer constructs.

Mike Swaim
Posted 08/09/2003 10:45AM #1
Thanks Mike, this is fun to play with. I can't remember the "formula" (or plot) of the number of stars of a given (sub-)magnitude -- does anyone know?

(MATH ALERT)

In principle, one can define a "Richness of Field" function:

RF(visual magnitude limit, aperture, magnification)
= expected number of visible stars in the FOV

possibly normalized for maximum exit pupil (7mm; it could be a function of visual limiting magnitude and observer's age) and eyepiece AFOV (say 60*), and possibly other factors such as elevation, humidity, angle, etc.

Then, for a given visual magnitude limit, one could look for the combination of aperture and magnification that maximizes the RF() function, and call such a telescope a Richest Field Telescope -- RFT. My gut feeling is that the visual limiting magnitude is a major determinant in "scoping out" the RFT aperture/magnification -- i.e. different scopes under different skies.

In the extreme of dark skies, the unaided naked eye (7mm aperture, 1X power, 60* FOV) may come pretty close. But near cities (or under full moon) there are few naked-eye stars, so one needs extra aperture/magnification to darken the FOV background -- in order to see more stars. Using the calculator, I found the L.M. difference between 16X and 38X for a 4" refractor (and 40-year-old-eyes), to be 1.2 for mag-5.5 sky, 1.5 for mag-4 sky, and 1.7 for mag-2.5 sky. Higher magnification helps more when the sky is bright.

Plugging in the star-count as a function of magnitude, one ought to be able to figure out which telescope or binoculars is "RFT" under a given limiting magnitude. Does this make sense to anyone?

-- William Chang (Saratoga CA)