I have seen in several places the assertion that the optical quality of binoviewers does not matter in a practical sense. As I understand it the claim, it is saying that ALL prisms and beam spliters from the least expensive to most expensive binoviewers currently extant are above the minimal quality which would be visible to any observer.
I do not agree with this claim in principle. My hypothesis is that the surfaces of the beamsplitter and the lower portions of the prisms are far enough from the focal plane that a good portion of the surface is used to form each point on the image. Hence, quality matters and differences can be seen.
I do not have more than one binoviewer, so I cannot test either hypothesis.
Anyone done such a test at high powers (i.e. smaller focal length eyepieces) or have anything to add as to why one might or might not see any such differences?
Philip
I do not agree with this claim in principle. My hypothesis is that the surfaces of the beamsplitter and the lower portions of the prisms are far enough from the focal plane that a good portion of the surface is used to form each point on the image. Hence, quality matters and differences can be seen.
I do not have more than one binoviewer, so I cannot test either hypothesis.
Anyone done such a test at high powers (i.e. smaller focal length eyepieces) or have anything to add as to why one might or might not see any such differences?
Philip