Image of the day

Captured by
Ruben Tommasi

Andromeda Galaxy (M31)

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

15X70 Binoculars

Started by dogkat1, 09/20/2004 09:17PM
Posted 09/20/2004 09:17PM Opening Post
In researching the 15X70 "affordable/inexpensive" options:

Barska/Bear/Galileo - Occasional cheap sales ($50-60), coatings aren't very good, quality control problems... some people curse these while others say they are the best performance/price available

Celestron Skymaster - Better coatings, quality control problems. ~$64 w/ free shipping from Amazon. Some customers seem very happy, some mention receiving "crap". Isn't clear whether it has screws for correcting collimation problems.

Burgess - $99. Better QC. Some reviews seem to say these are identical to Skymasters.. possibly hand picked by Burgess to get the better units.

Oberwerk - Good coatings, $149. Some mention that it is the same design as all the others with better coatings.. a few post mention that is not true ad this is a unique design.

Makes my head spin. The Skymasters appeal to me due to the price... but if you can't correct the collimation...

Doug
Posted 09/21/2004 12:15AM #1
Douglas,

I own a pair of the Burgess 15x70s, one club member owns a pair of the Skymasters and another owns the Oberwerks. The owner of the Skymasters and I compare ours to each other. Other than better coatings and the external stamps we could not tell any difference. We were at the monthly meeting and did not do any viewing, although we plan to in the near future.

I did not have my pair when I viewed through the Oberwerks. The Oberwerks were nice to view through, but I can't compare them to the Burgess just yet. The one thing the I can say for certain is that each owner are very happy with pair 15x70s.

It's no telling where these binoculars come from. I think it is safe for me to say they all come from either China or Taiwan.

Good luck in your sorting out,

Pernel
Posted 09/21/2004 12:30AM #2
I owned two pair of the Oberwerks, one real good and one almost as good. Both were prone to needing collimation tweaking.
I now have a pair of the Celestrons, and they are essentially the same "appearance" as the Oberwerks, but much better images and collimation. They do have the collimation screws right under the edge of the covering, back at the rear near the prisms. I made a parallelogram mount and they are so much nicer to use when mounted.

Walt

Attached Image:

Walter's attachment for post 83171
Posted 09/21/2004 02:08AM #3
There was a neat coating comparison at the Oberwerk site:
http://www.oberwerk.com/products/mccomp.htm

I take it the "B" brand is the Burgess. Burgess now has type 2 15X70's that cost more but have better coatings.

Thanks for the input and that parallelogram mount is a good idea.
Posted 09/21/2004 04:34PM #4
I have the Barska 15x70s on a parallelogram mount and am really enjoying them. The focus seems a bit loose when viewing at steep angles but a piece of tape pretty much locked the focus for me. I use glasses when viewing and can just take them out and they are already in focus. Makes a great grab and go scope.
Posted 09/21/2004 05:29PM #5
I got the Celestron's at Christmas and once I got them tweaked using the directions on Cloudy Nights, they have been great when on a tripod. It is definitely worth taking the time to properly collimnate them as I was very unhappy with the performance before that.

Kevin Butler