Image of the day

Captured by
Arthur Hogan

Wizard Nebula

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

5" or 6" APO question

Started by ivanong, 10/29/2004 07:02PM
Posted 10/29/2004 07:02PM | Edited 10/29/2004 07:04PM Opening Post
Hi, I am planning to step up from my 4" Tak to either a 5" or 6" APO. My interest in an instrument in such a class will be visual planetary observation, double stars and also astrophotography. I already have a C9.25" and am quite happy with that for deep sky objects.

I have read that a jump from 4" to 5" is very noticeble while 5" to 6" is not. I have seen aperture v.s. light collection plots but can someone with first hand visual experience with this concur or disagree with this fact?

I ask this question becuase of the huge cost difference between a 5" and 6" and also mount requirements.

Thanks in advance for your opinions.
Ivan
Posted 10/29/2004 07:17PM #1
Depends on what you consider a 5" and 6" size. If you go from a 130mm to a 150mm, then the difference is 15% in resolution and 33% in brightness. If you go from a 125mm to a 160mm, then the difference is 28% resolution and 64% difference in brightness.

Roland Christen
Posted 10/29/2004 10:22PM #2

Get as much aperture as you can afford without sacrificing quality.

Keep in mind that the larger the scope, the better the mount needs to be.

Keep in mind that a big scope and a good quality mount will be heavy.

I have a Meade 152ED with an LXD750 mount. I also have a Celestron 9.25 on a Skyview Pro mount.

The C9.25 sees more use because it is easier to setup.
Posted 10/30/2004 12:24AM | Edited 10/30/2004 12:33AM #3
Ivan,

What about the TEC 140 (5.5"), seems to be a "best of both worlds" situation, and the wait is not too long.

I have the AP130EDF and really like it's portability. The view is much superior to a 4" Celestron Fluorite. So that's an easy one. Also I don't think mediocre seeing will have much of an effect on 4" or 5" aperture. The 6" APO's tend to get big and heavy fast. But when the seeing is really good, my Takahashi 152 will give obviously better detail. The problem is, the seeing around here varies a lot, which means the image detail may not be a whole lot better than the 5" with the larger aperture except for brief glimpses. But when the seeing settles down, the six inch comes into it's own, and then you want all the high quality aperture you can get. We had an unusually steady night at the Chabot observatory last month, and the old 20" refractor (Rachel) was running full aperture at a clean 800X. You know, there are a lot of rilles on the moon smile

Not an easy decision, but a lot of viewing can be done with a 5" scope on any given night. If you have steady skies, then go for whatever you can handle.

David Simons

David Simons