Well the weather has been so lousy here lately that all I have to look at with my Orion 80ED is an artificial star. The problem is that it is only about 20 feet away. I know that this introduces spherical aberration but I'm uncertain weather it is undercorrection or overcorrection that is introduced. Does anyone out there actually know how much SA is introduced with an 80mm f/7.5 scope at that distance? Thanks
A question about indoor star testing
Started by ddrake, 02/05/2004 11:53PM
Posted 02/05/2004 11:53PM
Opening Post
Posted 02/06/2004 01:52AM
#2
When coming from close object, rays from every point diverge. As the object gets closer, angle of divergence becomes significantly larger for marginal than for paraxial rays. It results in marginal focus, after refraction, being moved farther away from the objective. The effect is overcorrection.
Suiter gives a formula for the distance at which overcorrection grows to 1/4 wave (it is strictly for Newtonians, but he says it can be used as a general guide for fixed systems). It gives the distance in units of telescope's f.l. as d=14D/F^3, for D in mm. For an 80mm f/7.5 it gives d=2.65 f.l. or as little as 5 feet. If so, 20 feet should be fine. But you'd need very small point source:
not more than 0.05mm in diameter (definitely less than 0.1mm, which would equal the Airy disc angular diameter).
Another thing is that the focus would move some 2.5 inches farther back from the infinity focus location, and the converging cone would become somewhat wider inside the tube. If the baffles are tight, that could cause slight stopping down of the aperture, due to widening of the converging cone at the baffle location. Such stopping down would somewhat reduce inherent spherical aberration, although not likely significantly.
Suiter gives a formula for the distance at which overcorrection grows to 1/4 wave (it is strictly for Newtonians, but he says it can be used as a general guide for fixed systems). It gives the distance in units of telescope's f.l. as d=14D/F^3, for D in mm. For an 80mm f/7.5 it gives d=2.65 f.l. or as little as 5 feet. If so, 20 feet should be fine. But you'd need very small point source:
not more than 0.05mm in diameter (definitely less than 0.1mm, which would equal the Airy disc angular diameter).
Another thing is that the focus would move some 2.5 inches farther back from the infinity focus location, and the converging cone would become somewhat wider inside the tube. If the baffles are tight, that could cause slight stopping down of the aperture, due to widening of the converging cone at the baffle location. Such stopping down would somewhat reduce inherent spherical aberration, although not likely significantly.
Posted 02/06/2004 06:41AM
#3
Well surprise, surprise. The Orion ED-80 lens is
a Steinheil design with the concave element on the front.
I measure about 0.4 waves *under*corrected for a
star at 20 feet; looks fully illuminated. And about
0.2 waves *under*corrected at 38 feet. This scope
is more-or-less null corrected (better than 0.1 wave)
at infinity.
a Steinheil design with the concave element on the front.
I measure about 0.4 waves *under*corrected for a
star at 20 feet; looks fully illuminated. And about
0.2 waves *under*corrected at 38 feet. This scope
is more-or-less null corrected (better than 0.1 wave)
at infinity.
Funding Member