OK, this is my first post on Astromart! I want to buy Orion’s Astroview 120 ST (f5). I’ve read the reviews on cloudynights.com and understand that this is a rich field refractor only. (But, I figure I can stop the aperture down a bit if I want to increase the f-ratio.) Here’s the thing, I’m worried that I should buy the Astroview 100 mm instead because it has an adjustable lens cell, and the 120 mm doesn’t (which baffles me). Just to let you know, my future plans are to piggyback this on a Celestron 9.25 SC. Any opinions are greatly appreciated. Thanks!!
Adjustable Lens Cell - Important?
Started by Bolide, 08/31/2003 01:46PM
Posted 08/31/2003 01:46PM
Opening Post
Posted 08/31/2003 02:15PM
#1
AN adjustable lens cell is usually more important for longer focal length instruments than it is for the short tube variety. Simple stuff, realy...
Imagine that you are trying to sight in on a star with a 2000mm instrument. If its lens is .1 degree off then you will probably not see your star even if you were right on it. Now if your thing has a focal length of just 600mm and the same aperture then you are still gona get the star in the very wide field of view.
In all honesty, I have had a couple of these wonderful 120mm refractors (a Skywatcher 120 f8.3 and an Orion 120-ST) and have had no problems regarding colimation. If the manufacturer does his job (regarding the machining of the cell and assembly of the OTA proper) then you won't have problems. But to answer your question, no... an adjustable cell on the Astroview 120-ST is not all that important... besides, if you don't like it, Orion will take it back!
Imagine that you are trying to sight in on a star with a 2000mm instrument. If its lens is .1 degree off then you will probably not see your star even if you were right on it. Now if your thing has a focal length of just 600mm and the same aperture then you are still gona get the star in the very wide field of view.
In all honesty, I have had a couple of these wonderful 120mm refractors (a Skywatcher 120 f8.3 and an Orion 120-ST) and have had no problems regarding colimation. If the manufacturer does his job (regarding the machining of the cell and assembly of the OTA proper) then you won't have problems. But to answer your question, no... an adjustable cell on the Astroview 120-ST is not all that important... besides, if you don't like it, Orion will take it back!
Posted 09/01/2003 05:47PM
#2
Jeff,
this makes good sense. I ordered the Orion 120-ST, figure I will get it by the weekend. Very Excited!
Thanks Again!
Gleo,
I took a look at the at1010. I like it a lot, the nighthawk and the c11 will be a great combo. For now I'm going to stick with the 120ST. I wanted at least 4" of refractor aperture and the extreme portability for right now - I don't plan on getting the C9.25 until next summer. If I do go for the C9.25 I wont get the CG5 mount, not after all that I have read about it - I'll spring for something up to the job.
Thanks again!
James,
I hear ya, I was thinkin' that I would have to buy the mount and C9.25 optical tube separately. I know the C9.25 by itself taxes the CG5. The Atlas and the GM8 would probably be at the top of that list. I'm keeping my eye on the Goto equatorial arena though. I'm hoping to see some more affordable, but quality options appear over the next year or two - there seems to be growing competition so maybe. Thanks Again!
this makes good sense. I ordered the Orion 120-ST, figure I will get it by the weekend. Very Excited!
Thanks Again!
Gleo,
I took a look at the at1010. I like it a lot, the nighthawk and the c11 will be a great combo. For now I'm going to stick with the 120ST. I wanted at least 4" of refractor aperture and the extreme portability for right now - I don't plan on getting the C9.25 until next summer. If I do go for the C9.25 I wont get the CG5 mount, not after all that I have read about it - I'll spring for something up to the job.
Thanks again!
James,
I hear ya, I was thinkin' that I would have to buy the mount and C9.25 optical tube separately. I know the C9.25 by itself taxes the CG5. The Atlas and the GM8 would probably be at the top of that list. I'm keeping my eye on the Goto equatorial arena though. I'm hoping to see some more affordable, but quality options appear over the next year or two - there seems to be growing competition so maybe. Thanks Again!
Funding Member