Image of the day

Captured by
Ruben Tommasi

Andromeda Galaxy (M31)

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Apo spotting scopes

Started by ddrake, 01/23/2004 03:32AM
Posted 01/23/2004 03:32AM Opening Post
Can the high end apo spotting scopes such as the Ziess 77mm Televid and others really compete with the astronomical scopes such as the Televues? The price tags are high but they can never exceed about 80X with the eyepieces they come with. I guesss what I'd really like to know is could the optics be pushed to high mags and produce images that would compete with high end apos such as TV or AP?
Posted 01/23/2004 08:48AM #1
As Joe pointed out, the Televid is a Leica product. Zeiss makes the Diascope.

I own both the Leica 77mm Televid APO and a 70mm TV Ranger, and have tested both of these against a variety of 60-100mm scopes and spotters including the Pentax that Joe mentioned.

In my opinion, the Leica Televid APO with 20-60x zoom e.p. actually gives clearer, sharper images between 25-40x than the TV Ranger with good quality eyepieces producing similar mags. However, the max available mag. with the Televid is 60x, and there's noticeable image deterioration well before 60x. I'd say the usable range on it is about 20-45x, with powers over 50x getting progressively less enjoyable. The limitation is the eyepiece, not the objective. If fixed power eyepieces were available for it in higher powers, I'm sure that it would compete up to at least 90-100x.

With the TV Ranger, the mag. limitation is really the aperature & objective glass. In theory it should handle at least 140x, and you can find lots of stories on the 'net about people taking their Rangers/Prontos well above that. However, having attempted higher powers with this Ranger with numerous quality eyepieces (including various TVs and UO orthos), I can say that it's really not at it's best above about 80x.

The Pentax spotters are currently the only real choice if you really want a terrestial spotter that can take astro eyepieces. The others are all either astro scopes that can (with some difficulty) be used for terrestial targets, or are terrestrial spotters that don't have suitable eyepieces for higher mags. However, don't expect the Pentax PF-80ED to even come close to competing with the larger TVs (85, 102, 101, etc.) or the Taks or APs.

If you're primarily interested in higher power planetary viewing, I'd suggest not even bothering with anything much under about 100mm, with 150mm being even better.

Mike Swaim