Image of the day

Captured by
Bruce Karbal

VDB 142 Elephant Trunk HOO

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Astronomy Class "Lab Equipment"

Started by Alex McConahay, 11/18/2003 07:22PM
Posted 11/18/2003 07:22PM Opening Post
I've been asked, so I thought I would throw this question out to my closest friends:

What would you buy if you had a grant of $25,000 to equip a laboratory class at the University level? Some parameters include:
You want to have twelve "kits" (identical sets of equipment, a telescope or two, eyepieces, etc.)
Each kit will serve three or four students.
The students are taking a lab class to fulfill the general education requirements. They are not in the class as part of a full astronomy program.
The school is in a light polluted suburb, and meets ten evenings during a quarter. Most meetings are on campus, but there are two dark sky field trips.
In answering the question, you want to consider what these people should be taught, and how, and what kind of equipment they need to learn this.
Portability, durability, ease of use, and such things should be considered as much as (or perhaps more than) quality of the optics.
The Lab already has half a dozen eight inch LX-90, C-8's and so forth, including three or four goto models.
The grant is not for an observatory or planetarium.

Alex
Posted 11/18/2003 08:41PM #1
Hi Alex,

A couple of questions before your question can be answered.

Are these students solely doing labs? Do they also have lectures? If so, what are they being taught?

How long are the night classes?

Does the 10 classes constitute the entire length of the course?

Cheers,

Maurice

* Teach a man to fish and you feed him for a day.
* Teach a man to use the internet and he won't bother you for weeks.
Posted 11/18/2003 10:12PM #2
You have $25k, or about $2k per team.
First:
Get each team
-an orion 8" f6 dob with autostar (take it away to teach star finding, give it back for quick lectures on DSOs). Or just get 6 autostars.
-An Orion ed80 on an alt/az mount
-A couple of functional but cheap UO Plossl eyepieces and a decent barlow for the short tube.
Total cost $1000 or so/team

Second: get each THREE teams a 5" f12 or f15 D&G refractor on an Atlas mount. You can end up with four of these. maybe only three if you add some more extras like eyepieces. Definitely four if you sell the AP focuser and replace with lower end but still nice version (don't need that much precision at f15 anyway). If you sell the AP focusers and stick with 3 scopes you can get more barlows, more eyepieces, nice finders, etc.

You ended up with
12 dobs. Handy, indestructible, low maintenance. Good light gathering. Functional DSOs. Kids can learn about mirrors.
12 apochromatic ST80s. portable, good for field trips, good for moon, wide scanning, learning sky.
3 long refractors. Great views, wonderful for planets. Look cool.
Posted 11/19/2003 12:59AM #3
Seems like you don't have any apos. Try the orion 80's on vixen great polaris's and you'll still have enough money for some 10" lx200gps's, 7" lx200gps maks, or 4 inch apos.
Posted 11/19/2003 08:12PM #4
Rob, and others,

Thanks you for your suggestions. It was not until I started thinking in these terms till I realized how much $25,000 could buy--when you really decide on what is useful to a student in that position.

Another interesting thing I noticed--Since this was posted yesterday, we have had a lot more people respond to central obstruction v. clear aperture and Hands-on optics (and so forth) than we have had comment on this problem. What's that say? (and please don't turn the thread here--it is food for thought--I don't want a reply.)

Alex
Posted 11/19/2003 09:10PM #5
I would be very concerned with durability and tuning. The scopes need to perform to the highest quality everytime with the least amount of tuning. You will the not have the following comments made, "Scope #5 is the best and scope #9 is terrible. or Stay away from scope #3, it's a dog." Ask yourself, Is this a class on how to navigate the sky only or does it cover equipment care and tuning? These questions will help you in your equipment selection.

- Tim