Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

Dual Clusters near Antares

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

celestron 9.25 OTA. Why so special?

Started by robert_rule, 01/30/2003 10:00PM
Posted 01/30/2003 10:00PM Opening Post
I have been looking for something to complement a Traveler on an AP 600 mount. I've been reading a lot about this OTA. I am sure that this has come up before but what makes it appear to be so special? Also, is there a great range in quality now that the company has been taken back over by professionals? Finally, any particular dealers that will make sure that everything is in excellent shape? I am leaning towards Company Seven.

Thanks for your time,

Bob
Posted 01/31/2003 12:11AM #1
Optically, advantages of the c9.25 come from its slower primary (~f/2.4). For one, it makes it easier to produce aspheric corrector within certain tolerances, the way it is manufactured. Then, its field curvature is milder, nearly 300mm, comapred to ~170mm in a "regular" 8" SCT. This makes for a better field performance.

There are speculations that its primary is aspherical, in which case secondary could be spherical (that would be a plus, since small aspheric convex mirrors are also tricky to manufacture) but it's not so. I knife-edged it at the radius of curvature, and the shadow is perfectly straight (characteristic of a spherical mirror). Secondary is more strongly aspherized than in a "regular" design, possibly even mild hyperbola, but it's more likely that they kept it a strong ellipse.

Also, due to lower secondary magnification, chromatism in the c.9.25 is about twice lower than in a "regular" sct. That shouldn't be a dramatic advantage by itself (due to relatively low chromatism in a "regular" sct), but combined with better, on average, corrector figure and milder field curvature, it is probably enough to give noticeably better impression.
Posted 01/31/2003 04:28PM #2
One thing I've always wondered was: if the 9.25 is so superior optically, why doesn't Celestron adopt it's unique design for ALL of it's line of SCTs?