Image of the day

Captured by
Ruben Tommasi

Andromeda Galaxy (M31)

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Celestron 9.25 vs 11 - planetary performace

Started by pestrada, 02/12/2004 03:55AM
Posted 02/12/2004 03:55AM Opening Post
I currently own a Nexstar 8 gps with great optics. I will be upgrading to something larger in the near furture.

Would like to hear opinions (only planetary performance) from those who have used Celestron's recent 9.25 and 11 SCTs. Have you noticed the 11" perform any better?
Thanks,
Pablo
Posted 02/12/2004 04:49AM #1
I have an Ultima 9.25. Great performance on the planets. But if you are going up in aperture, go for the 11, you will notice the difference.

The 9.25 is not much more portable than the 11 either. They have almost the same tube lengths.

I have not had a chance to view through any of the 11's. But reports indicate they are every bit as good optically as the 9.25. Especially the recent Nexstars.

Donnie
Posted 02/12/2004 10:42AM #2
I have the nexstar11. First Views were awfull, took time to collimate it, and now the views are fantastic.

The Nexstar11 has actually given me my best view of Saturn and Jupiter so far. Saturn was sharp, several bands that darkened as they moved to the poles.

I have Blacknight Binoviewers and the views a espically awsome, However the most planetary detail I was able to distingish came form a 2" E.P. 36mm Barlowed with a 3x Barlow. I have found barlowing 2" Low Powered E.P. are giving my best views.

It's my first SCT SCT deliver more then I was lead to believe. I also have 7" MAk and a 8" Mak Newt.

The first Step towards failure is trying. - Homer Simpson
Posted 02/12/2004 05:41PM #3
Buy the N11. The OTA isn't much heavier or less portable than the 9.25 and the way Celestron packages the Nexstar series the 11 is a deal and the 9.25 not so much so. If you’re buying just the OTA the cost difference is substantial and the 9.25 is more of a bargain.

I bought the 9.25 which is mounted on a G11. If I could have afforded it though, I would have purchased the 11 OTA.

I think Mark's experience was an aberration. The 11s I've looked through were consistent with the 9.25 in sharpness and contrast.

Actually the 9.25 has a slightly larger secondary obstruction than the 11. Some might tell you that given identically configured optics the 11 would always outperform the 9.25 based on the design alone w/o having to rely on aperture.

I believe the cult following for the 9.25 was generated on the following:

In years past, it was easier to configure the optics on the 9.25 due to the longer focal ratio of the primary and secondary. However, today there is less sample error in the scopes produced by Meade and Celestron and it is unlikely that there is anything magical about the 9.25 over the 11. Certainly nothing that would overcome the larger aperture and smaller secondary.

Todd Gross owns/owned an excellent sample that was reviewed by him and by Ed Ting and published on the web.

If you're going to spend that kind of money though, buy local and test drive first.

Clear Skies,

Ron
Posted 02/12/2004 11:55PM #4
Hi,

I went through the same thing and ended up with the NS11 GPS. The difference in weight is just a few pounds. The difference in aperture and resolution is huge. Most NS11s if not all are excellent optically nowadays. If the optics don't look good it's most likely a collimation problem.

Here are a few solar system images with the NS 11:

http://web.tampabay.rr.com/jsuro/saturn-12272003.htm

http://web.tampabay.rr.com/jsuro/mars-08272003_reproc.htm

http://web.tampabay.rr.com/jsuro/14_day_moon-12072003.htm

http://web.tampabay.rr.com/jsuro/moon_plato.htm

http://web.tampabay.rr.com/jsuro/moon_mountains.htm

Best,

Jose Suro
Tierra Verde, Florida