I'm in a little bit of a conundrum. I'm putting together a 10" f/4.8 dob and I need a secondary mirror. I have been told that I should try and obtain a 100% fully illuminated field of .5". I have also been told that the central obstruction should be kept to a minimum. This is where the problem is, I can't have both. A 2.14" secondary only gives me a 100% FIF of .36". It does appear though that the drop off is gradual. In other words 100% FIF is .36", at .67" the illumination drops to 94% at the edge. Not a big change. A 2.6" secondary gives me a 100% FIF of .93"(overkill really). Of course the 2.6" will give me a central obstruction of 26%.
I will be using a binoviewer, so my main ep focal lengths will range from 4mm-17mm. If I understand the concept of all of this correctly, using a 2.14" secondary would be fine because even a 17mm ep would still have 94% illumination at the edge. BTW, if I go with the 2.14" secondary the barlow of the binoviewer will protrude into the lightpath of the primary mirror by about a half inch. If I go with the 2.6" I can fix this problem, plus have a larger FIF for my 31mm Nagler. What would you do?
After I posted this message I checked out the specs again on NEWT. When it tells you the 100% FIF, let's just say it's 15mm, does that mean that a 15mm ep will be 100% fully illuminated, or does that mean a 15mm field stop? If it's the field stop then I misunderstood the concept above.
I will be using a binoviewer, so my main ep focal lengths will range from 4mm-17mm. If I understand the concept of all of this correctly, using a 2.14" secondary would be fine because even a 17mm ep would still have 94% illumination at the edge. BTW, if I go with the 2.14" secondary the barlow of the binoviewer will protrude into the lightpath of the primary mirror by about a half inch. If I go with the 2.6" I can fix this problem, plus have a larger FIF for my 31mm Nagler. What would you do?
After I posted this message I checked out the specs again on NEWT. When it tells you the 100% FIF, let's just say it's 15mm, does that mean that a 15mm ep will be 100% fully illuminated, or does that mean a 15mm field stop? If it's the field stop then I misunderstood the concept above.