Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Central obstruction and 100% FIF.

Started by explore, 12/04/2003 05:12PM
Posted 12/04/2003 05:12PM Opening Post
I'm in a little bit of a conundrum. I'm putting together a 10" f/4.8 dob and I need a secondary mirror. I have been told that I should try and obtain a 100% fully illuminated field of .5". I have also been told that the central obstruction should be kept to a minimum. This is where the problem is, I can't have both. A 2.14" secondary only gives me a 100% FIF of .36". It does appear though that the drop off is gradual. In other words 100% FIF is .36", at .67" the illumination drops to 94% at the edge. Not a big change. A 2.6" secondary gives me a 100% FIF of .93"(overkill really). Of course the 2.6" will give me a central obstruction of 26%.

I will be using a binoviewer, so my main ep focal lengths will range from 4mm-17mm. If I understand the concept of all of this correctly, using a 2.14" secondary would be fine because even a 17mm ep would still have 94% illumination at the edge. BTW, if I go with the 2.14" secondary the barlow of the binoviewer will protrude into the lightpath of the primary mirror by about a half inch. If I go with the 2.6" I can fix this problem, plus have a larger FIF for my 31mm Nagler. What would you do?

After I posted this message I checked out the specs again on NEWT. When it tells you the 100% FIF, let's just say it's 15mm, does that mean that a 15mm ep will be 100% fully illuminated, or does that mean a 15mm field stop? If it's the field stop then I misunderstood the concept above.
Posted 12/04/2003 06:38PM #1
Wow,
I am using a 2.6" on a 15" Newt. That seems big for a 10", but I am no expert.
Floyd

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 12/04/2003 07:29PM #2
Chris, I have a 10" f/6.2 and use a 1.83" diag. I feel sure the 2.14 will be totally acceptable for your uses. I even doubt you will notice any falloff with a really widefield ep like the 31mm. That's not to say thay there won't be falloff, there surely will be. It's just that the eye is pretty accomodating in that arena and you likely could not see the difference from 2.14 and 2.5/2.6. It's also doubtful you could detect the difference in diffraction and CO effects between the two, so I would recommend the 2.14.

Walt
Posted 12/04/2003 07:29PM #3
It corresponds to field stop size, not focal length, but the only thing I noticed that you got wrong was the bit about the 17mm eyepiece having a 94% illumination. To figure that we'll need the field stop diameter of the particular 17mm eyepiece in question.

The 1/2" protrusion is what would bother me. Too bad you can't find a 2.3" secondary.

Your 31mm Nagler will work either way. People get too uptight about off-axis illumination levels for visual use. Heck, my 7" drops to less than 20% illumination at the edge of a 40mm Pentax XL or UO MK-70 Konig. Does that stop me from using the 40mm eyepieces with it sometimes. Heck no. The view's fine.
--
Mike
Posted 12/04/2003 10:58PM #4
Unless you are doing photography, or specifically
are building this scope for low power, you do not
need very much FIF. Your eye will not be able to
see the light fall off at low power, but a
large CO will definitly eat up planetary contrast.

I would probably use the 2.14" diagonal, and move
the primary mirror closer by 0.5" to get the
binoviewer Barlow out of the light path. Your
FIF would then be about 0.26" but this is OK.