Clarifying methods used for Interferograms on Anta

Started by fblue, 03/07/2005 06:22PM
Posted 03/07/2005 06:22PM | Edited 03/07/2005 08:53PM Opening Post
Hello all,
Because of a comment made about the results I posted of Interferograms by Antares about possible manipulation or masking of edges or defective areas. I thought I would post part of a correspondence I had with Antares about these comments.
The following is an excerpt from this letter for you to read and make your own judgment about the validity of their testing and documentation.
"We measure all of our mirrors at 100% aperture. No Mask data manipulation what so ever. We only trim the outside perimeter to 5 points as shown on the interferogram. True a 1/50 wave PV optic is a rare & prized piece of work; It does happen enough, "here", that I can say it is almost a weekly event.
As I explained in our earlier phone conversation, we produce 4" and 6" transmission Flats for "EDIT" itself. Producing a 6" 1/25 wave PV TF is much more difficult than finding 1/40 or 1/50 wave mirror on a block of twelve or more 1.83" secondary mirrors.
We use these secondary mirror blocks as a testing platform to measure the performance of our 52" & 60" Continuous Polishers. After these blocks have polished on a daily basis for a week or two, we test these mirror blocks on a Zygo GPI. When we see the test exceeds a 1/20 wave PV, we retire that mirror block and start a new one.
There is no pressure to produce these mirrors. They're finished when they're finished. Why wait a week or two you ask?
(The first few days, in the life of a mirror block) If you leave a mirror block set up on the interferometer overnight, the next morning, you will see that the test has changed from what was seen night before. We wait until we see no change in a 24 hour period. After a week or more, most, if not all of the blocking stresses have dissipated, so when we de block, the mirrors change very little. Some change, or "spring" in the wrong direction and some spring in the right direction! That is what you have there. A mirror that corrected itself in the right direction. Yes, I like to take credit for all of our fine mirrors but sometimes I have to say I just got lucky with a few of them. If you do a few thousand of these mirrors, you will have plenty of rejects, and on the inverse, a few exceptional pieces to show for your time.
We've been contracted once again by a major customer, to correct a problem that "EDIT" could not remedy."
I hope that this resolves the issue of testing done and quality statements concerning these flats. smile

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 03/07/2005 07:50PM #1
Floyd Blue said:

Hello all,
Because of a comment made about the results I posted of Interferograms by Antares about possible manipulation or masking of edges or defective areas. I thought I would post part of a correspondence I had with Antares about these comments.
The following is an excerpt from this letter for you to read and make your own judgment about the validity of their testing and documentation.
"We measure all of our mirrors at 100% aperture. No Mask data manipulation what so ever. We only trim the outside perimeter to 5 points as shown on the interferogram. True a 1/50 wave PV optic is a rare & prized piece of work; It does happen enough, "here", that I can say it is almost a weekly event. .....

Floyd,
I'm not sure what this means. It almost sounds like, "We don't mask the edge, we trim it." I'm not knowledgable enough to know the difference.

I pulled out my documentation on a couple of mirrors I got from Antares and looked at it more closely. I noticed that the images shown are not elliptical, kind of like the "ends" of the mirror were chopped off. This is from a 3.1" diagonal. On the paper for the 1.83" diagonal the Fringe Map and the main plot look elliptical, so the 3.1" definitely looks strange.

Kevin
Posted 03/07/2005 08:19PM #2
I am not accusing anyone of manipulating their data. I am trying to educate you guys on what to look for under the hood, so to speak. Sometimes data is incomplete, and as far as these flat interferograms, I would not accept them myself if I were buying this item from an unknown vendor. I have been led down the garden path too many times, plus I know a bit about testing and what I would like to see in the data.

Do not read more into what I say than what I say.

If you all are uncomfortable with any of this, then say so and I will say no more on the subject of optical quality, optical testing etc. God knows that Peter Ceravolo has tried so many times in the past to elevate this subject among amateurs, and then be rebutted and shat upon by some who always seem to know better.

Roland Christen - heading out to Hawaii for R&R.