Image of the day

Captured by
Ruben Tommasi

Andromeda Galaxy (M31)

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Does anyone re-coat lenses?

Started by Bill in Ballard, 02/12/2005 03:54PM
Posted 02/12/2005 03:54PM Opening Post
I have been trying to find someone to re-coat a refractor lens. I've spoken to
Majestic & Clausing. Neither will do a lens which has been previously coated. I contacted Sirius and they don't do it anymore. Any leads would be greatly appreciated. Thank you, Bill
Posted 02/12/2005 04:50PM #1
Bill, try Edmund Industrial Optics. edmundoptics.com

Mark Rice
Keep it dark, or at least keep it quiet. wink
Ultima 2000... and other things
Posted 02/12/2005 05:04PM #2
Lens coatings don't come off easily. If they are hard multi-coatings, they will need to be ground off. They will never etch off with any kind of acid. That, of course means repolishing and refiguring, which is very costly.

If it's a single layer mag-fluoride, then some form of agressive acid eching can be used to remove the coating, but it will also damage the glass underneath. It will open up all the fine sleeks that may be present and turn them into nasty deep score marks. That means polishing and re-figuring again.

Lens coatings are not the same as mirror coatings. In a mirror, the aluminum coating sits on top of the glass in a relatively thick layer, and has a very tenuous adhesion to the glass. Aluminum etches very quickly with ferric chloride solution, which is quite harmless to the glass underneath. A lens does not have a reflective coating, rather it is an anti-reflective coating. This coating is ultra-thin. When it is applied correctly, the glass is heated to 600 degrees F, which increases the mobility of the glass surface molecules. The glass essentially "opens up" and allows the coating material to fuse well into the glass layer. In effect, the coating and the glass bond very strongly to a certain depth, and in order to remove it, you have to rip the surface molecules of the glass apart with the acid etchant. Weak etchants like ferric chloride won't touch this coating. You need to use hot sulphuric acid, and let it bathe for a time.

If the lens is any good at all, I would leave it alone. The other option would be to send it to D&G Optical and ask Barry Greiner to repolish it for you. He has the expertise to do this right.

Roland Christen
Posted 02/12/2005 05:28PM #3
Hi Bill,

I can't vouch for these folks, but their prices seem very reasonable.

http://www.thinfilmcoating.com/default.htm

Oddly enough, I work at a place with about 20 large coating chambers, (they even coated the Hubble mirror) and I can't get a single mirror or lens coated !!

I had always heard Sirius was an amateur friendly shop. Maybe no-more.

David Simons