Ellipitcal Flats

Started by fblue, 06/11/2004 12:39AM
Posted 06/11/2004 12:39AM | Edited 06/11/2004 12:40AM Opening Post
If you had your choice of Elliptical Flats for you DOB, which maker would you choose?
I am entertaining getting a replacement and would like some opinions. I will not mention who I am considering because I do not want to influence your choices. grin
Floyd

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 06/11/2004 02:10AM #1
Protostar or Antares Optical. Depends whether the size you need is in stock.
Posted 06/11/2004 02:58AM | Edited 06/11/2004 03:00AM #2
I'll vote for Antares Optics. I've used them for my last two purchases, the 1.5" for my 10" f/8 planetary dob, and just recently the 1.3" for my new 6" f/6 porta-dob. I really like them, they supply a very comprehensive and complete 3-d interferometer test chart so you can see exactly what you've got, and where the highest peak and lowest valley is. Their prices are indexed to wavefront accuracy so you get exactly what you pay for.

The last 1.3" flat I got from them was rated to 1/25 wave P-V... but then I saw the test report, and nearly all that error is at the edge -- a 1/25th wave 'turned edge' grin -- in fact the vast majority of the mirror's surface (which is pretty much all that will be catching the on-axis light cone), away from the edge, is closer to 1/70th wave P to V!! Yeehah!
Posted 06/11/2004 10:28AM #3
I will be ordering a new three vaned secondary mount and a ULS Quartz diagonal from Protostar soon. I have purchased two mounts and secondaries from Protostar in the past and I have been very pleased with their products.

I also like that Bryan Greer is part of the astronomy community and writes informative articles for Sky & Tel and has a lot of useful information on his web site. I also know I can phone him and ask questions and get a balanced opinion on what will meet my needs.

Gary Weber