Image of the day

Captured by
Arthur Hogan

Wizard Nebula

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

EQ-1 Vibration essential tremor problem

Started by RoDnSuE, 01/03/2005 02:15AM
Posted 01/03/2005 02:15AM Opening Post
Hi all,
I've been having a blast with my new scope when the weather corporates but have a problem.
Anyone have experiance with reducing vibration in an EQ1 mount?
I recently purchased an Orion Starmax 90mm mak with the EQ1 mount and aluminum tripod legs.
The problem I am having is somewhat of a medical problem. I have a disorder called essential tremor which causes tremor in mostly my hands and head especially when concentrating on something.
When I'm focusing, the tremor makes it hard to tell when I am focused since the mount and scope are jittering with my hand. I end up moving it a bit and then removing my hand to see if I need to focus better. It doesn't help much that my head is shaking as well :C
I read somewhere on AM that someone packed sand into the legs of thier aluminum tripod and it seemed to help eliminate vibration.
If anyone has any experiance with this, I would like to hear about it. It's a real pain in the "you know what"
Do you think a more rigid mount system would help?
What about wooden legs?

Thanks,
James
Posted 01/03/2005 02:46AM #1
James,
maybe the answer to your problem is a remote control focuser. One that has a cord that attaches to a box with buttons for in and out focus. This could stop the tremors from being transmitted when doing the fine focus.
These are available.
Floyd

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 01/06/2005 02:37PM | Edited 01/06/2005 02:40PM #2
James:

It is my experience that mounts like the EQ-1 tend to be "shaky" and that using a long focal length scope like the Orion 90mm Mak increases the problem, it has a long optical "lever arm" which increases the effect of small vibrations.

In general, tripod mounted scope are sensitive to vibration, one of the advantages of the DOB design is that the mount is solid, right there on the round instead of cantilevered off into space so that focusing a Dobsonian can be done in "real time."

The many different types of Motor Focusers are there essentially for this very reason, it is difficult to focus scopes mounted on a tripod.

OK, enough of the negative, what can you do about it??

There are several things you can do.

First, make sure that all the nuts and bolts on the mount are tight. Just a small amount of looseness can make a big difference.

Second. Do not extend the legs any more than is necessary. Keeping them as short as possible helps reduce the flex in the legs. Try observing from a chair so that you can avoid extending the legs. Keeping the legs short will really make a difference.

Third: It is my experience that the problems with these mounts rests in the legs. Surprisingly, wooden legs are significantly stiffer than the supplied aluminum legs so a set would probably solve your problem.

Schemes like sand in the legs may help, I have never done that but you can make a set of wooden legs if you are handy with tools. Fixed length legs can be made from some 2x2s and a bit of drilling, sawing and routing. I think this would pretty much solve your problem.

One of the reason people are willing to pay many thousands of dollars for a mount is because such mounts can be very solid and come with tripods that are well designed and heavy enough to make the mount vibration free.

But for the rest of us, just keeping the legs short, maybe stiffening the legs or replacing them with wooden legs, observing on dirt rather than on concrete, these are the things that can make a significant difference.

Best wishes

jon isaacs
Posted 01/06/2005 03:04PM #3
James,
As others have stated, an Eq-1 mount is not really ever going to be a stable mount, and this becomes more of an issue with a long focal length scope like your Mak. Really Orion shouldn't sell that combo together in my opinion. You could try some modifications, like sand in the tripod legs, wooden legs, etc., but the mount just isn't machined accurately enough to ever really be rock solid. Vibration suppression pads very likely would help the problem noticeably though.

In my opinion however, the best solution would be to step up a couple of notches on the Eq mount chain and get something inherently more stable. Orion's Astroview (basically the same as Celestron's CG-4, Skywatcher Eq 3-2, and others) would be a good match. One of these with nice wood legs would be even better.

A focus motor also could be useful, or as a cheaper alternative, you could just get a focuser extension cable (sold on that other auction site for Meade's ETX scopes - search "Meade ETX" and you'll find a bunch); basically this is just a stiff cable (~12" long or so) that attaches to the scope's focuser knob (or to the shaft behind it) and allows one to focus the scope without touching it directly. This might be helpful for you and allow finer focuser control.

Best of luck in any case!
Tim

Best of