Image of the day

Captured by
james carter

North American Nebula NGC7000

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

FS128 vs C14 color correction

Started by gnowell, 05/15/2009 12:40PM
Posted 05/15/2009 12:40PM | Edited 05/15/2009 12:43PM Opening Post
Roland a while back on the "whiteness of saturn" thread you mentioned that the very slight off-white color in the C14 and FS128 were due to the same reason. Recently you posted in "one for roland" a more detailed appraisal of an ED refractor vs. an SCT. What is confusing me is that you suggested that the removal of a touch of violet form the in-focus image will cause a slight yellowing of the hue in an SCT and in an FS128. In the passage below however the discussion seems to indicate that the FS128 will have classic refractor purple (not as much as an achro, but a tad) but that the SCT will have a white light fringe. (And in fact I have seen fatter stars in luminance images with SCTs; the FS128 will show some color under "stress," but not as much as the ED Vixen doublet; the c14 has never shown color).

What is not penetrating my noggin is how both a purple fringe and a white light fringe can be equivalent in changing the hue of Saturn?

thanks
Greg N

p.s. I wanted to thank you for running all the graphs on c14 vs Mak, I am going to upload those into our archives at Yahoo! C14 for discussion. GN




Post from previous thread:


>Should this lead to purple fringed stars in SCT photographs>

The chromatic aberration of a doublet ED refractor is different than that of an SCT. In the SCT, the 70.7% zone has no color error, below that zone and above that zone there is color error, but of opposite sign (this is known as pure sphero-chromatism). The result is that for the shorter and longer wavelengths the light simply extends beyond the smallest Airy disc size to form a ring of white light that extends outward some 80 to 90 microns (Airy diameter for a C14 is ~14 microns). While the main light is concentrated inside the Airy disc, the extraneous light forms a faint halo that extends outward and decreases in brightness. In so doing it makes the diffraction rings brighter and lowers the brightness of the central disc. The result is an overall lowering of the contrast and an enlarging of the star diameters in a CCD image (over that of a perfect 14" optic).

In a refractor that has chromatic aberration, it generally occurs primarily in the blue and is a result of blue defocus plus sphero-chromatism. The result is a fairly bright blue-violet out-of-focus disc surrounding the Airy Disc.

Typically, sphero-chromatism produces a white halo while longitudinal chromatism produces a colored halo.

While sphero-chromatism in an SCT does not produce a colored halo, it does reduce the polychromatic Strehl. Visually it might not be all that important because the eye filters out the ends of the spectrum, especially for those over age 55 due to the eye lens becoming yellowed. Imaging wise, it does affect the star sizes and the potential resolution, except in the green where the Strehl can be 100% (if figured accurately). Nevertheless, a well made Mak can produce a polychromatic Strehl over 95% for the entire photo-visual wavelength range.

Rolando

"Scope will get you through times of no money better than money will get you through times of no scope." --Freewheelin' Franklin