Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Help with Star Test Result

Started by traderjoao, 06/26/2004 05:52PM
Posted 06/26/2004 05:52PM Opening Post
8O
Hi,

I have done a star test of a new scope yesterday and I am puzzled with the results. I am wondering if someone can help.

The scope is a Borg 100ed refractor. I have use my lowest focal length Naglers for the test (7mm and 4.8mm). These give an amplification of x91 and x133 in this scope.

The difraction rings look concentric and well defined in the outer-focus image. However, in the inner-focus image the rings are difficult to discern. They are still the same size and concentric but they seem to be more faint and, in addition, there were lots of random disturbances happening. It looked like several collored light rays emanating from a higher luminosity point which kept moving fast! The effect resembles the one from a plasma ball with a moving center and many different colors.
The effect was reproducible with different stars and diagonals.
Also, it cannot be seeing conditions because one of the outer focus images showed perfect rings, and I have star tested simultaneously another small scope, a Lomo Astele 95 mm, and this weird effect was not present.

I have been trying to find on the web something about this without much luck. I did found the following report which claims that for APO refractors one should not expect the two outer focus images to be the same:

http://voltaire.csun.edu/roland/startest1.html

I am evaluating this scope to decide if I keep it or not, so
any help will be welcome.
Posted 06/27/2004 01:31AM #1
Here are some pictures of the star tests I have done today.
This is not a perfect test but it is probably good enough to show the problem.

The in-focus images have a very bright central point and some radial "outbursts". The out-focus images look pretty good.

These were taken during the day today with a "artificial" star (see focused pictures). I have used a 4.8 mm nagler and and digital camera (Dimage 7i).

Does anyone recognize what the problem could be?

Attached Image:

traderjoao's attachment for post 80907
Posted 06/27/2004 08:10PM #2
Thanks everyone for the comments. You have been very helpful.
I have already learnt a lot.

My artificial star is indeed at about 300-400 feet. But, note that the patterns I saw with it were similar to the ones with a real star. Yesterday night, I have tried it again with similar results.

I will try your suggestions.

The star images do not really snap to focus. I have been thinking it was the helical focuser, which is more sensitive than the focuser in my Mak. I guess, this is probably related.
Also, there is some flaring of the stars when in focus which I do not see in the Mak.

I have looked at the moon but I only have eyepieces to go up to x133. At that zoom, the image looked nice with some color on the moon edge.
Posted 06/28/2004 07:43PM #3
Today, I have done a test that many have suggested.

I have stopped down the aperture of the scope from 100 mm to 85 mm.

Now, the difraction rings in the inner-focus image look very sharp. The image seems to be perfect both inside and outside focus. Even the flaring I was seeing is mostly gone from the inside focus image.

So, does this definitively indicate a turn-edge problem with the lens?
The flaring I was seeing when the image was focused was also reduced significantly.

Now the silly questions!
How significant is this problem?
Would you buy the scope with this problem? The price is inline with the
price of the other 100ED Borgs sold in Astromart.
Will I be better off paying a few hundred dollares more and get a new ED scope? Or, a few less and go with a achromat?
Now, I know I can reduce the aperture and get perfect images but then shouldn't I just buy a 80 mm scope?