Last year I bought a Coulter 13.1 inch thin mirror model (early 90s ?) in good shape and at a good price. I've learned to collimate pretty well I believe and have some reasonable eps (wide angle meades), not naglers but still OK. I do have a 9mm Type 1 (or 2) nagler I bought from a fellow club member.
So with all of that my DSO, double star, planet, etc. views have been reasonable but not tack sharp. Of course its a fast scope and not an ultra quality mirror. I don't see the detail of Jupiter that some appear to see with smaller scopes. Stars do not resolve to a point, more like a small blur with points (but not caused by the spider vain). The stars at best focus look like a very small "V".
I tried to do a star test the other night with the 9mm and a 2x barlow. This is the highest magnification available to me at the moment. I could see the defraction rings (6 or 7) and the dark central obstruction when I racked in past focus, and just a blur of light (no defraction rings)when I racked out. I believe it was a fairly steady night for seeing.
The defraction rings bounced around and were very spikey.
From the above, and what I've read on the forum, I now believe that I'm seeing the effects of the boundary layer just above my primary and likely some tube currents.
I thought my mirror was cooled down and truth be told there was not a 10 degree change from day to night (Houston area). I don't think there was a cool down issue with the mirror but I still believe there is something going on with the air inside the tube (16-inch sonotube) that is causing some of the spikeyness I'm seeing in the focused stars and during star testing.
So I plan to install fans similar to what Mr. Sower installed. Hey what can it hurt.
I'll let you know it this helps. If so, it may encourage others it give it a try.
regards
david roberts
So with all of that my DSO, double star, planet, etc. views have been reasonable but not tack sharp. Of course its a fast scope and not an ultra quality mirror. I don't see the detail of Jupiter that some appear to see with smaller scopes. Stars do not resolve to a point, more like a small blur with points (but not caused by the spider vain). The stars at best focus look like a very small "V".
I tried to do a star test the other night with the 9mm and a 2x barlow. This is the highest magnification available to me at the moment. I could see the defraction rings (6 or 7) and the dark central obstruction when I racked in past focus, and just a blur of light (no defraction rings)when I racked out. I believe it was a fairly steady night for seeing.
The defraction rings bounced around and were very spikey.
From the above, and what I've read on the forum, I now believe that I'm seeing the effects of the boundary layer just above my primary and likely some tube currents.
I thought my mirror was cooled down and truth be told there was not a 10 degree change from day to night (Houston area). I don't think there was a cool down issue with the mirror but I still believe there is something going on with the air inside the tube (16-inch sonotube) that is causing some of the spikeyness I'm seeing in the focused stars and during star testing.
So I plan to install fans similar to what Mr. Sower installed. Hey what can it hurt.
I'll let you know it this helps. If so, it may encourage others it give it a try.
regards
david roberts