Interferogram vs. Foucault vs. Ronchi

Started by Joe Bruessow, 12/24/2004 03:33PM
Posted 12/24/2004 03:33PM | Edited 12/24/2004 03:36PM Opening Post
Okay all of you experts. Time to start the flames... Most ATM's and many professional opticians use the Foucault knife edge and/or Ronchi gratings to test the figure of their optics. How reliable are these tests when compared to an interferogram analyzed by computer software? How much does the optician's "visual interpretation" of the wavefront at the knife edge affect the reliability of the results in the Foucault and Ronchi tests? In other words, are some people much better at interpreting this data (i.e. Zambuto, Spooner, and the like) than the average Joe?

When newly established companies come on board making claims of 0.95 Strehl ratios using the Foucault test should we take these with a grain of salt because the data may not be reliable/ accurate?

Finally, is the interferogram that much better than the other tests? I know the fringes that are anaylzed give a good representation of the entire surface of the mirror vs. the Foucault test only analyzing certain areas/ zones of the mirror and assumes the figure holds true for the entire surface. (I also know that some people perform tests on more zones than others to give a more accurate representation of the mirror's surface). I also understand that the ronchi test is more of a qualtitative test and sort of art when looking at the results...

Can a ronchigram also be analyzed with computer software?

Anyway, these were some ideas I have had and always meant to ask... they may have been answered before, and perhaps I have some misuse/ misunderstanding on some basic information, but that is why I posed the questions.

Merry Christmas... Happy Holidays... Winter Solstice to All! wink
Posted 12/24/2004 03:58PM #1
Joe,
At least you didn't start another APO vs reflector fire.
These are all good tests but the advantage interferometry has is that it gives you a quantitative 3D (X-Y and height) view of the mirror surface. Other tests lack one of these attributes, i.e. qualitative or one dimensional. For this reason interferometry is great at detecting astigmatism or asymmetry that is hard to detect or quantify in other tests and astigmatism is often the biggest contributor to a lower Strehl ratio. I often chuckle when I hear a Srehl of near 1.0 quoted for a mirror. But interferometry of parabolic mirrors must be done with a null of some sort and this is where the problems can come in (Hubble). Even so interferometry is the choice of the pros.

Ed Jones
Posted 12/24/2004 04:56PM #2
An interferometer is a "machine" and there is no subjectivity. It is very accurate.

A Foucault test is not so accurate and you can "measure" (I say measure) only few things like spherical correction, turned edge... However, an experimented optician can "see" (but only see) much more using a Foucault test. Thus, the couple "Foucault test" + " Experimented optician" can reach a very good accuracy.

If you have a Foucault test in hands, it is very important to know from where...
Posted 12/25/2004 04:27AM #3
>>Can a ronchigram also be analyzed with computer software?

Not that I know of. But have you seen

http://members.aol.com/ronwin20/

It will give you something to campare with.

However, since the Ronchi is not all that quantitative, I don't see how it would lend itself to computerization.

Alex