Ok, let's start a new one!

Started by fblue, 06/08/2004 05:28PM
Posted 06/08/2004 05:28PM Opening Post
Just to warm things up in here I propose this question.
Why is it that people say that a dirty mirror with a lot of dust and spots on it is OK? No real light lost from those countless bits of dirt and all that cover the whole mirror and scatter light all over.
But then turn around and say that cleaning the mirror may cause small micro-scratches that will scatter light?
Seems to me that all those small bits of dirt and spots have got to be scattering a lot of light. 8O
Come on, start the flames. 8)
I like to keep the mirrors clean myself, but I do take care not to scratch them.
Floyd

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 06/08/2004 06:01PM | Edited 06/08/2004 06:03PM #1
You ask me, they are both (dust and scratches) a question of degree. The scattering impact of dust particles will depend on (1) the diameter of each particle relative to the mirror's diameter and (2) the density of particles distributed on the mirror's surface.

I suspect that things have to be pretty dirty to start to have a detectable impact. I like to keep my mirrors clean too but have yet to see a detectible change in performance from cleaning. Mind you, I don't let them get too grubby to start with. I too am very careful in cleaning, and in my opinion you run a greater risk of scratching the optics if you wait longer to clean, since you're having to get more gunk off at one time.

I have also seen varying degrees of scratching. I have seen multiple hairline sleeks have no detectable effect. Even 3 or 4 BIG scratches, like you'd get from a few swipes with a medium-sized chunk of gravel, having no detectable effect on a fairly large mirror (like 14"-16"). But get lots (and I mean lots) of cross-crossing ultra-fine scratches on a tiny secondary and you've got a serious light scatter problem.

It's all a question of degree and severity, relative proportional area impacted, etc.
Posted 06/08/2004 07:59PM #2
Dirt and small particles don't reflect much light and serve to shadow themselves on the mirror so only the tiniest amount of light loss and scattering occur.
I once had a 10" newt that I would drop black carpet fibers from a sweeper bag that would induce static magnetism in the fibers onto the mirror to reduce overall brightness of planets at any given image scale. The contrast was improved enough that I could use less mag and see more detail especially when seeing wouldn't permit the highest mag levels.
If we use good cleaning methods (lets don't start that one again)I think it's best to let a mirror get really darn dirty before cleaning. As mentioned before, the secondary does need to be clean always.

?????????
John