Image of the day

Captured by
Bruce Karbal

VDB 142 Elephant Trunk HOO

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Over corrected one night under corrected another?

Started by Bill in Ballard, 03/22/2005 02:01AM
Posted 03/22/2005 02:01AM | Edited 03/22/2005 02:03AM Opening Post
I live in Seattle where the skies & temps. are never completely steady. My 4 inch F15 refractor seems almost immune to the viewing conditions.
However I have a 6 inch F8 refractor that seems to struggle with unsettled conditions. Star testing can be very frustrating.
Is it possible for a scope to star test slightly over corrected on one night,then undercorrected on another? thank you, Bill
Posted 03/22/2005 06:51AM #1
My 6" F8 refractor runs over-corrected when it gets
cold. Its like 1/10 wave P-V overcorrected at 60F,
but shifts to 1/4 wave overcorrected at 30F.
My guess is that the rear (negative) element
contracts faster as it gets cold. Might also
have something to do with the anti-dew heater
I use (keeping front element warmer than rear
element).

You can also get a large effect while the scope
is initially cooling after you take it outside.
The front element will cool and contract first,
sending it under-corrected for
a while, until the rear element catches-up.
Posted 03/23/2005 05:19AM | Edited 03/23/2005 05:21AM #2
I have had or seen several scopes that reacted oddly to cooldown:

1) a 90s C8 that was perfect at room temp but would develop 1/4 wave of spherical at cool temps--and never settle out until it warmed back up! Celestron replaced the coatings and the problem went away; I had heard of stress in coatings, but wow.

2) a TV60 that was perfect at room temp but would go triangular on stars at cold. Loosening very slightly the three radial tilt screws made the problem go away.

3) a fanless 7" mak that tracked the air temp very closely, it would cool, setttle out as the temp stablized in the early evening, then go weird again as the temp dropped later. This must be the reason they invented fans.

"--Granted, that's a worse case scenario. The destruction might in fact be ... limited to our own galaxy."