Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Portable (affordable) Planetary Scope

Started by nycdutch, 10/05/2003 08:47PM
Posted 10/05/2003 08:47PM Opening Post
What is a good pick for a portable, quick-look, grab-and-go planetary scope (consider weight, bulk, cool-down, and set-up time)? DON'T suggest a 4" apo! Unless you have one with a mount to sell me for under $1500 wink.

Basically I want an scope that will show just enough planetary detail to make it worth looking from night to night, but can be taken out of an apartment and used on a sidewalk in an urban setting without too much hassle. Being able to take it on vacation (by plane) would be a bonus.
Posted 10/05/2003 09:31PM #1
hi,

A used Televue Genesis SDF fits the bill.


Larry Citro
Posted 10/06/2003 04:16AM #2
Ian,
I know I may get blasted for this suggestion but here goes:
Meade 125 ETX with UHTC.

I have had one since last Christmas and while it is not a perfect scope, I think it is worth considering.

On the good side the optics are wonderful. The views are very sharp and very contrasty. The star test is outstanding. It has done very well for me on the Moon and planets, and it has been a big surprise for me on deep sky objects. For example, over the summer I have had excellent views of M27, M13, M17 (with a UHC filter) and M8 among other objects. M31 was especially wonderfully a few weeks ago. Last winter the view of M42 was a notch behind my old 7” Mak, but still very impressive. The Autostar has been just great.

The mount was improved a while back. Make sure you get a new one that has metal in the fork arms. The old arms that were all plastic were pretty bad. No, the ETX is not built like my old LX200, but it has worked very well for visual use. I have the travel case and transport the instrument to a darker site on a regular basis. I keep it in the basement on the tripod and can easily carry it out to the yard as a complete unit when I view at the house. The finder is not good for much more then centering alignment stars.

Finally, I have also used the scope for viewing the Eagles here in Wisconsin. Half way across the Wisconsin River I could see the detail of the bird’s iris.

I know there have been many negative reviews of the ETX scopes out there. My new one with the “uber” coatings has been a pleasant surprise. As a frame of reference, I have owned a number of 7” Maksutovs, a 3.5” Maksutov, and a few 4” APOs.

Good luck, Paul G.
Posted 10/06/2003 04:25AM #3
One more thing... GOTO is actually useful for planets.

My best view of Mars was right around dawn -- the sky had brightened to the point I could no longer see Mars naked eye, but in the eyepiece the contrast was perfect. Then I lost it while trying to wake up the family... sure wish I had GOTO!

-- William
Posted 10/06/2003 05:58AM #4
IMHO,

For refractor, you could consider Stellarvue, I'm impressed with their scopes, S&T has rated their Nighthawk as a Hot Product, a complete system is 800 bucks. Or their 102DN, complete system under $1200 It's had great reviews. Check Astronomy and S&T for reviews as well as Ed Ting and Cloudy Nights.
Posted 10/06/2003 11:45AM #5
Hi Ian,

A Vixen 102ED f6.5 (used) on a new Orion SVD mount. Rock solid, portable, quick to cool. I own one of these and a fluorite and can tell you that the views they provide are very apochromatic. I also had an Orion 127 Mak, not a bad scope at all but nowhere near as nice as either Vixen.

Clear Skies,

Steve
Posted 10/06/2003 01:34PM #6
One of the nicest portable telescopes on an equatorial mount is a 4.5-inch newt, if you can find one with excellent optics -- a tall order with all the junky ones out there now. But they can occasionally be found.

An old Orion Spaceprobe 4.5 with exceptional optics gave me very pleasing planetary images and kept me out in the backyard for hours on end with Jupiter and Saturn, ultimately rekindling my interest in astronomy enough to build a serious planetary dob.

You could also do something like, take a standard 6" f/8 dob like an XT6 and replace the optics with a premium planetary mirror (Mark Harry or the like), the result would be a very fine scope that would spank any 4-4.5" competitor on planets and still be *much* cheaper than a 4" apo.

Posted 10/06/2003 02:34PM #7
I'm going to second Gerald's recommendation of considering Stellarvue. I bought a used 80/9D (they come up for about $350 or less fairly frequently) to give to a nephew, and was amazed by how close it came to my TV-102 on the moon and planets. Very nice mechanically, too.

Be careful not to buy one of the shorter achromats, however, unless you know you don't mind false color.

Steve