I was wondering if anyone might be able to tell me if a rainbow effect on the mirror means it's time for re-coating.This looks similar to an oil slick on water..The mirror is a 16" Meade from the 1980's..Other than this discoloration (which is only visible from an angle), the coating seems fine, with no holes or peeling..Also, could anyone tell me how I can determine the mirror's wave myself...Finally, what would it cost to have this mirror re-coated, and what additional cost for re-configuring if needed?..A lot of questions, I know, but I'd greatly appreciate any assistance or suggestions...Thanks, Wayne Douglas
Re-coating Mirror
Started by astron9999, 04/01/2004 02:36AM
Posted 04/01/2004 02:36AM
Opening Post
Posted 04/01/2004 02:41AM
#1
Wayne,
It is hard to tell what it is, could be slight oxidation. Have you tried cleaning it lately? Could be residues from your cleaning.
Nevertheless, from your description, it does not need recoating. Place the mirror on a table in a room with moderate lighting. Step away from the mirror about 3-4 feet. Does it look normal at this angle, from this distance, without an intense light shining directly on it?
If so, avoid the desire to give the mirror multiple cleanings, place it back in the tube and enjoy it a few more years.
Randy
It is hard to tell what it is, could be slight oxidation. Have you tried cleaning it lately? Could be residues from your cleaning.
Nevertheless, from your description, it does not need recoating. Place the mirror on a table in a room with moderate lighting. Step away from the mirror about 3-4 feet. Does it look normal at this angle, from this distance, without an intense light shining directly on it?
If so, avoid the desire to give the mirror multiple cleanings, place it back in the tube and enjoy it a few more years.
Randy
Randy Roy
Posted 04/01/2004 12:18PM
#2
>>>Finally, what would it cost to have this mirror re-coated, and what additional cost for re-configuring if needed?..
Here is one guy that does mirror coating. He did my 12.5 incher, the price was right, the turn around quick and it was friendly transaction in all regards.
http://home.covad.net/~alcoat/
Jon
Here is one guy that does mirror coating. He did my 12.5 incher, the price was right, the turn around quick and it was friendly transaction in all regards.
http://home.covad.net/~alcoat/
Jon
Posted 04/01/2004 01:59PM
#3
Wayne,
I agree with Randy that it does not sound like your mirror needs recoating. You would be talking about places where the coating is thin enough to see through, or irregular areas of the mirror--part of it looking different from other parts.
I assume your interest in "wave-rating" is merely curiousity. Are you happy with the images? Then the wave rating--whatever that means-- is good enough. If not, it is not. (Although it could be a lot of things besides "wave rating" affecting your view.)
But, to answer your question. You can probably easily get a test by visiting a local ATMer (Amateur Telescope Maker) by contacting your local Astronomy Club. If you are in SOuthern California, please come to a RATS (Riverside Amateur Telescope Makers) meeting. (See Rivastro.org.)
If that is difficult, get any good book on star testing or telescope making, and you should get the right procedures.
I would not go to the difficulty of shipping the mirror off someplace--you have the possibility of damage, and a bunch of other tribulations-- and all you will find out is a number that means little unless you intend to have it refigured for sure because you are unhappy with performance.
Alex
I agree with Randy that it does not sound like your mirror needs recoating. You would be talking about places where the coating is thin enough to see through, or irregular areas of the mirror--part of it looking different from other parts.
I assume your interest in "wave-rating" is merely curiousity. Are you happy with the images? Then the wave rating--whatever that means-- is good enough. If not, it is not. (Although it could be a lot of things besides "wave rating" affecting your view.)
But, to answer your question. You can probably easily get a test by visiting a local ATMer (Amateur Telescope Maker) by contacting your local Astronomy Club. If you are in SOuthern California, please come to a RATS (Riverside Amateur Telescope Makers) meeting. (See Rivastro.org.)
If that is difficult, get any good book on star testing or telescope making, and you should get the right procedures.
I would not go to the difficulty of shipping the mirror off someplace--you have the possibility of damage, and a bunch of other tribulations-- and all you will find out is a number that means little unless you intend to have it refigured for sure because you are unhappy with performance.
Alex
Posted 04/01/2004 03:00PM
#4
I believe that the rainbow effect you're seeing at an angle is normal. Someone can correct me if I'm wrong, but I think you're seeing interference from the SiO (or SiO2) overcoat.
The best way to tell if you need recoating is to hold it up to a strong light and see if you can see through the coating. If it looks real translucent then it may need recoating.
The best way to tell if you need recoating is to hold it up to a strong light and see if you can see through the coating. If it looks real translucent then it may need recoating.
Funding Member