Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Re: Sidewalk Test

Started by fblue, 10/15/2004 10:28PM
Posted 10/15/2004 10:28PM | Edited 10/15/2004 10:32PM Opening Post
Ok, OK, so I can't follow instructions! wink I never said I was a genius. grin
Now, this final pic shows them from over 5' up and straight above with black caps on each. :S
So, what about this one? I guess this should be right.
Still, the results seem about the same. XL, Radian, Nagler, UO, UWA, Parks in that order it would seem. But I still would wonder about the deep red of the XL, is that good or bad? Is it better to have a little red and other colors like the Radian or not?
Floyd


Attached Image:

fblue's attachment for post 19436

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 10/15/2004 10:52PM | Edited 10/15/2004 10:54PM #1
Now you're cooking with gas. The Pentax and Radian are a mile ahead. The UAW shows typical Meade piss-poor coatings. Maybe their new line will be better.

Even though the UO Ortho says Multi-coated, I doubt seriously that all surfaces are. Probably only one, the eye lens top is multi-coated.

The red coating on the Pentax means that they are off a bit from ideal. Normally when lenses are coated in a chamber, hundreds are placed on a large fixture. The evaporant is down below about 3 - 4 feet away. The distance from the evaporant to the glass is not quite equal for all the different elements, so the layers are not all exactly the same thickness for every lens. The outermost lenses on a fixture normally get slightly less exposure to the evaporant, hence their layers are a bit thinner. Thinner coatings will have a warmer color, thicker a colder blue color. The eye is very sensitive to slight differences, but in this case it amounts to less than a hill of beans.

Roland Christen
Posted 10/15/2004 11:38PM | Edited 10/15/2004 11:40PM #2
I know it is just a photo on the internet, but if this thing, and subject, is correct the Nagler and UWA look like expensive, small mirrors; real bad. I think the UO looks better than the Nagler in this photo, and the Parks is a disaster.

Wasn't there a topic recently on "Nagler vs Pentax"? If so, maybe something like this might help on that decision for prospective buyers. I was looking toward the Pentax anyway, long before today, based on the recommendations of another optician that you all probably already know and love... smile But, I would hate to be the first guy in 8 months to post anything other than plans to buy every eyepiece ever made by TeleVue! 8)

S. Sherrod

S. Sherrod
Posted 10/16/2004 03:26AM #3
You can't follow instructions? I forgot to put the caps on the bottom so I did a good resolution test on my shoe laces.