Hi everyone. I want to draw off the knowledge of the group here if I may. My question concerns resolving power and magnification.
What I am curious about is this. Lets say you have a 4" scope. For the sake of the argument, lets assume it is a top quality APO. At what point does increasing magnification result in no gain in detail?
The reason I ask is that winter time around here means one thing. Lots of frustration when trying to observe the planets. The jetsream settles in right on top of us when it makes its turn to the East. This creates a lot of turbulence. Most nights in the winter I am limited to <200X. Unfortunately right now and for the past few years the gas giants are most favorably placed during the winter months. In a few years perhaps when they are better viewed in the summer, then this would be a moot point.
With that in mind and the fact that I am once again looking for something more portable and with quick cooldowns your responses would be most appreciated.
I have a N8GPS now that I really like. However, DSO's are not high on my list of objects to observe. Of course the extra aperture "should" allow for increased planetary detail. But if I am limited to the powers I mentioned above--is that benefit fully realised? Of course exit pupil and image brightness are another concern. But based purely on planetary detail, would an 8" scope provide more detail than a 4" scope when used at the exact same magnification--under 200x?
If 200x is not beyond the 4" APO's resolving ability, then I am strongly considering getting one. I like the wide field of view that small refractors provide. Of course we have maybe a few nights each year where I live where the extra aperture would be fully utilised. But in the past 5 years I can count on both hands how many nights we have had like that.
I hope this doesnt turn into a refractor vs reflector war. That is not my intention. I am just curious about performance at the powers I mentioned above. In fact, some of the best planetary detail I have seen in the past few years has been at or around 160x.
Thanks to all in advance.
Donnie
What I am curious about is this. Lets say you have a 4" scope. For the sake of the argument, lets assume it is a top quality APO. At what point does increasing magnification result in no gain in detail?
The reason I ask is that winter time around here means one thing. Lots of frustration when trying to observe the planets. The jetsream settles in right on top of us when it makes its turn to the East. This creates a lot of turbulence. Most nights in the winter I am limited to <200X. Unfortunately right now and for the past few years the gas giants are most favorably placed during the winter months. In a few years perhaps when they are better viewed in the summer, then this would be a moot point.
With that in mind and the fact that I am once again looking for something more portable and with quick cooldowns your responses would be most appreciated.
I have a N8GPS now that I really like. However, DSO's are not high on my list of objects to observe. Of course the extra aperture "should" allow for increased planetary detail. But if I am limited to the powers I mentioned above--is that benefit fully realised? Of course exit pupil and image brightness are another concern. But based purely on planetary detail, would an 8" scope provide more detail than a 4" scope when used at the exact same magnification--under 200x?
If 200x is not beyond the 4" APO's resolving ability, then I am strongly considering getting one. I like the wide field of view that small refractors provide. Of course we have maybe a few nights each year where I live where the extra aperture would be fully utilised. But in the past 5 years I can count on both hands how many nights we have had like that.
I hope this doesnt turn into a refractor vs reflector war. That is not my intention. I am just curious about performance at the powers I mentioned above. In fact, some of the best planetary detail I have seen in the past few years has been at or around 160x.
Thanks to all in advance.
Donnie