What is the minimum scope needed to see the Encke division?
Seeing Encke
Started by g1957, 01/05/2004 06:30PM
Posted 01/05/2004 06:30PM
Opening Post
Posted 01/05/2004 10:08PM
#2
I recently had a night of damn good seeing (not superb) and could make out the Enke Minima at 450x with a 8" f/8 reflector. Apparently, ( I say this not from experience, but from reading elsewhere) the Enke Division (or Keeler Gap depending on your preferred nomenclature) can be seen with an 8 inch reflector during nights of superb seeing and powers of 500x or more.
I think there are claims of this feature being observed in smaller apertures (Apos), but I am not aware of any confirmations - nor have I sought to find them. My chances of observing through a 7" Apo is pretty miniscule.
Gary Weber
I think there are claims of this feature being observed in smaller apertures (Apos), but I am not aware of any confirmations - nor have I sought to find them. My chances of observing through a 7" Apo is pretty miniscule.
Gary Weber
Posted 01/06/2004 01:31AM
#3
Number of prominent planetary observers claim the the Gap can be seen with a 6" aperture, I tried for eight years using my 155 f/9 AP with absolutely no luck and that with every eyepiece combinatins plus a binoviewer & powers up to 360x.
The only time that I got a glimpse of this feature and it lasted about 10 seconds, never to be seen again, was with a TEC 250/20 with a binoviewer operating at about 420x.
If I have to guess, a high quality 14" aperture would be the minimum if you expect a fighting chance of "really" capturing the Encke long enough to really enjoy the view.
Thanks,
Vahe
The only time that I got a glimpse of this feature and it lasted about 10 seconds, never to be seen again, was with a TEC 250/20 with a binoviewer operating at about 420x.
If I have to guess, a high quality 14" aperture would be the minimum if you expect a fighting chance of "really" capturing the Encke long enough to really enjoy the view.
Thanks,
Vahe
Posted 01/06/2004 09:44AM
#4
Since I've never seen the E division in 6 or 8 inchers, I was curious what various authorities had to write about Encke's division. Some of this may prove interesting to this discussion:
In "Advanced Amatuer Astronomy" by Gerald North, he writes that he's never seen Encke's division (despite years of observing with a range of scopes up to at least 18.25"). He theorizes that the Earth's atmosphere puts a resolution limit on seeing the really fine divisions in the rings. He basically suggests that am. astronomers straining to see the divisions may be tricked by differing ring intensities.
In the Saturn chapter of "Sky Watcher's Handbook", former director of BAA Saturn section, Alan W. Heath writes "Subjective impressions of divisions in the outer ring can be caused when small telescopes are used in poor seeing and the outer ring is not steady, sharp or well seen. Differing brightness in the parts of a ring can also give the impression of a faint division." He suggests a large aperature, really good seeing conditions and a steady image for objectively verifying ring divisions other than Cassini's.
In "The Amateur Astronomer's Handbook", James Muirden suggests that Encke's division has been recorded in a 9 inch scope, but study of the feature requires a much larger aperature. Perhaps of more interest in that section he also discusses how many well noted astronomers such as Herschel and others, completely missed the entire crepe ring until it was discovered by the Bonds at Harvard with a 15 inch scope. That brings him to Herschels dictum: "When an object is once discovered by a superior power, an inferior one will suffice to see it afterwards."
In "The Backyard Astronomer's Guide" by Dickinson and Dyer, the authors claim that the Encke division should properly be called the Keeler gap, for James Edward Keeler, who 1st saw it using the 36 inch refractor at Lick's Observatory. Then in a contradiction appearing on the same page, they state that the gap has been seen by 6 inch refractors, but then go on to state that a minimum of an 8 inch refractor with a very experienced observer is needed to see this feature. They claim that neither of the authors has seen it with the 26 inch Naval refractor at 330x.
So, I don't know if any of that will prove useful to anybody else, but it at least suggests to me that I shouldn't feel too bad for having never seen the E division myself.
Regards,
Mike Swaim
In "Advanced Amatuer Astronomy" by Gerald North, he writes that he's never seen Encke's division (despite years of observing with a range of scopes up to at least 18.25"). He theorizes that the Earth's atmosphere puts a resolution limit on seeing the really fine divisions in the rings. He basically suggests that am. astronomers straining to see the divisions may be tricked by differing ring intensities.
In the Saturn chapter of "Sky Watcher's Handbook", former director of BAA Saturn section, Alan W. Heath writes "Subjective impressions of divisions in the outer ring can be caused when small telescopes are used in poor seeing and the outer ring is not steady, sharp or well seen. Differing brightness in the parts of a ring can also give the impression of a faint division." He suggests a large aperature, really good seeing conditions and a steady image for objectively verifying ring divisions other than Cassini's.
In "The Amateur Astronomer's Handbook", James Muirden suggests that Encke's division has been recorded in a 9 inch scope, but study of the feature requires a much larger aperature. Perhaps of more interest in that section he also discusses how many well noted astronomers such as Herschel and others, completely missed the entire crepe ring until it was discovered by the Bonds at Harvard with a 15 inch scope. That brings him to Herschels dictum: "When an object is once discovered by a superior power, an inferior one will suffice to see it afterwards."
In "The Backyard Astronomer's Guide" by Dickinson and Dyer, the authors claim that the Encke division should properly be called the Keeler gap, for James Edward Keeler, who 1st saw it using the 36 inch refractor at Lick's Observatory. Then in a contradiction appearing on the same page, they state that the gap has been seen by 6 inch refractors, but then go on to state that a minimum of an 8 inch refractor with a very experienced observer is needed to see this feature. They claim that neither of the authors has seen it with the 26 inch Naval refractor at 330x.
So, I don't know if any of that will prove useful to anybody else, but it at least suggests to me that I shouldn't feel too bad for having never seen the E division myself.
Regards,
Mike Swaim
Posted 01/06/2004 02:34PM
#5
What's missing from this discussion is the impact of Saturn being at its nearest right now. Obviously, that should make a difference, but how much?
Whatever I saw was far more than I have ever seen before. I was very lucky indeed to get very good seeing, and very good transparency four and three nights before Saturn's closest approach.
Whatever I saw was far more than I have ever seen before. I was very lucky indeed to get very good seeing, and very good transparency four and three nights before Saturn's closest approach.
Posted 10/28/2004 02:21PM
| Edited 10/28/2004 09:13PM
#6
There are several references to observations of Encke's divison in A.F.O'D.Alexander's "The Planet Saturn: A History of Observation, Theory and Discovery" among those mentioned:
Captain Henry Kater did most of his observing with a pair of Newtonian reflectors, a 6 1/4" F/6 and a 6 3/4" . On 17 December 1825 "the conditions were very favorable: no wind and a very slight fog. With the larger reflector (6 3/4") he saw a very distinct image but nothing unusal, but with the 6 1/4-inch Watson and his most perfect single eyepiece (power about 280)....'I fancied that I saw the outer ring separated by numerous dark divisions, extremely close, one stronger than the rest dividing the ring about equally...'
On 7 September 1843 W. R. Dawes viewed Encke's through a 9" reflector belonging to W. Lassel- "I presently perceived the outer ring to be divided in two.....The outline of the planet was very hard and sharply defined at a power of 450; and the primary (Cassini's) divison...very black and steadily seen all around the southern side." At 400x he could glimpse Encke's but could not see it at all at lower power.
On 25 November 1850 Dawes was armed with a 6 1/3" achromat of "very fine" quality. Using powers of 282 to 425 "Dawes ... was satisfied that in finest moments, a very narrow and short line was discernible on the outer ring near it's extremities."
On November 29: "having applied higher powers, and viewed the planet steadily for a considerable time, I obtained several satisfactory glimpsesof a division near the extremity of the outer ring. It was occasionally seen with power 323; but far more certainly with 460."
On 26 November 1854 Dawes, using a 7 1/2" achromat, described Encke's as " a very dark, narrow, well defined line concentric with the ring, and about one-fifth of it's breadth."
In 1852 W.S. Jacobs appears to have observed Encke's division with a 6.2" refractor at Madras Observatory at a power of 365.
Captain Henry Kater did most of his observing with a pair of Newtonian reflectors, a 6 1/4" F/6 and a 6 3/4" . On 17 December 1825 "the conditions were very favorable: no wind and a very slight fog. With the larger reflector (6 3/4") he saw a very distinct image but nothing unusal, but with the 6 1/4-inch Watson and his most perfect single eyepiece (power about 280)....'I fancied that I saw the outer ring separated by numerous dark divisions, extremely close, one stronger than the rest dividing the ring about equally...'
On 7 September 1843 W. R. Dawes viewed Encke's through a 9" reflector belonging to W. Lassel- "I presently perceived the outer ring to be divided in two.....The outline of the planet was very hard and sharply defined at a power of 450; and the primary (Cassini's) divison...very black and steadily seen all around the southern side." At 400x he could glimpse Encke's but could not see it at all at lower power.
On 25 November 1850 Dawes was armed with a 6 1/3" achromat of "very fine" quality. Using powers of 282 to 425 "Dawes ... was satisfied that in finest moments, a very narrow and short line was discernible on the outer ring near it's extremities."
On November 29: "having applied higher powers, and viewed the planet steadily for a considerable time, I obtained several satisfactory glimpsesof a division near the extremity of the outer ring. It was occasionally seen with power 323; but far more certainly with 460."
On 26 November 1854 Dawes, using a 7 1/2" achromat, described Encke's as " a very dark, narrow, well defined line concentric with the ring, and about one-fifth of it's breadth."
In 1852 W.S. Jacobs appears to have observed Encke's division with a 6.2" refractor at Madras Observatory at a power of 365.
Posted 10/28/2004 08:34PM
| Edited 10/28/2004 08:43PM
#7
When I was 13 or 14, with my very young, sharp eyes and my mighty 4" F12 Dynascope reflector with its 167X achromatic ramsden eyepiece that cost the princely sum of $49 I saw the Encke division on a couple of occassions under Louisiana skies.
Now I was outside with the scope virtually every clear night for a couple of years so for any super steady night skies I was there. Do you believe I really saw it or was my young teenage imagination working overtime?
I have looked at Saturn since with 8", 10" 16", 18" and 20" scopes and not seen it. But the skies were never as pristine as I remember them when I was a kid living in a small, unpolluted town.
Jeeze, I miss those skies and my teenage vision.
See you.
Tom B.
Now I was outside with the scope virtually every clear night for a couple of years so for any super steady night skies I was there. Do you believe I really saw it or was my young teenage imagination working overtime?
I have looked at Saturn since with 8", 10" 16", 18" and 20" scopes and not seen it. But the skies were never as pristine as I remember them when I was a kid living in a small, unpolluted town.
Jeeze, I miss those skies and my teenage vision.
See you.
Tom B.
Funding Member