Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

So, Interferometer or Foucault?

Started by fblue, 03/04/2005 02:19AM
Posted 03/04/2005 02:19AM | Edited 03/04/2005 02:19AM Opening Post
Well, It is another one of those unanswered questions. Do you rely on Foucault or do you only trust an interferometer?
Are results derived from any other testing but Interferometer to be dismissed as inadequate?
Seems like Carl Zambuto produces some mighty fine figures and smooth finishes based on Foucault tests.
Do other manufacturers have better figures because they test by machine?
Makes one wonder doesn't it?
For my money the proof is in the eyepiece. Nothing can convince me a bad mirror is good but nothing can convince me a good mirror is bad either. grin
If the mirror is great the images will also be great. If the mirror is poor the views will also be poor. If the finish is rough the contrast will suffer. If the figure is poor then the images will suffer. Seems simple to me. Maybe I am just simple? 8)

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 03/04/2005 02:39AM #1
>>If the mirror is great the images will also be great. If the mirror is poor the views will also be poor. If the finish is rough the contrast will suffer. If the figure is poor then the images will suffer>>

What is great and what is poor? I'm willing to bet that you cannot see the difference between a 1/4 wave mirror and a 1/40 wave mirror in an 18" size.

Today there is software available that allows you to determine the wavefront error of your telescope. Basically it requires that you take two out-of-focus images of a star using a 16 bit CCD camera. These images are then analyzed and calculations of P-V, RMS and Strehl are done. Send me a pix of a star out of focus both inside and out, 16 bit Fits image, defocused to 150 pixels. I need to know the focal length and aperture.

Roland Christen