SolarMax40 vs MaxScope40

HI,

I read the revue in Sky and Tel but want to know if
anyone else has compared these two products.

The article mentioned the darker background in the
MaxScope. I have a TV-85 but I like the idea of
two ways to view the sun at the same time.

Any thoughts?

Phil Shute

Phil,

I have the Maxscope 40 and a TV85 and have been able to observe through both setups. I believe it is a question of personal preferences only. I do enjoy having the Maxscope ready to go at all times. I especially like to use a lighweight Bogen tripod and pan head for almost daily quick peeks of the Sun. This setup is way too light for the TV85 which is over twice as heavy. But, I also like mounting the MS40 atop of the TV85 on my Tak EQ mount, especially at public events where I can show white light filtering through the 85 to give context to the Ha.

One consideration: I used to travel by air a lot and take my scope with me. If I were still doing that, I would prefer the SM40 to prevent taking multiple scopes.

Many will tell you the Maxscope is optimized for Ha, but in my comparisons, the views through the SM40, even through pretty cheap scopes, was comparable to my MS40.

Best wishes with your selection.

Randy

Thanks to all for the postings, information and links.
I'll be making a decision soon.

Many thanks!

Phil