telescopes and Quality.

Started by fblue, 02/10/2005 12:16AM
Posted 02/10/2005 12:16AM Opening Post
I would like to take a moment to restate a few comments that I have made here in another thread.
All scopes made in mass production will have varying degrees of quality in the production run. It doesn't matter whether it is a refractor or reflector this applies to all.
With this said, you can certainly find an exceptional and a unacceptable scope within a given production run. This is common to all manufacturers.
If you get one of the better of any brand then you are usually happy. If you get one of the worst then you are unhappy.
If you buy something from one of the premier makers then you expect the quality to be the same throughout the production. This is not even the case unless each scope is assembled and individually tested by the maker. Many of the best makers do just this, but some do not! Those that sell imports can not very easily do that of course, so some will get to the customer with a problem and this is just the way it is with mass production.
You can not expect the same quality of optics and construction from a scope that cost a fraction of the other scope. This is not being realistic. smile
If you cannot afford the premier scope, then you must choose the best that your money will buy. This is not always a simple thing. With the above stated production restrictions, you may have to try before you buy to insure that the scope you purchase meets your expectations. You will have to choose between the type of tube and glass used to make the scope as well as the accessories provided with it. You will have to use experiences with the product out in the field to help you in making this choice, this is why so many people recommend going to star parties to actually try these scopes. This is invaluable in my opinion.
So, with all this said, most of the mass production scopes are a good bargain because their price is hard to beat. It would be hard to build one for the cost they sell for lately.
But if you are looking for the highest quality, then you must be prepared to save your money and wait for opportunity to purchase a scope of the quality you are expecting. There are no Premier scopes for sell for $500. wink The mirror I just bought from Carl Zambuto, a 10" f/6 cost $1,000 and this is just a mirror. I will have much more invested before it becomes a scope. smile But this is what I wanted and I just saved my money and sold my other scopes to get the quality that I knew I really wanted to own. But, this does not mean that someone that buys a $500 10" scope will not be just as pleased with their purchase as I will be with mine. It is all about what you can afford to own and not what others own. If you can not afford a Porsche, you drive a Volkswagen! They are both fine cars, right? grin
Have a good day and an even better night, thanks for letting me get this off my mind.


[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 02/10/2005 01:32AM #1
"The mirror I just bought from Carl Zambuto, a 10" f/6 cost $1,000 and this is just a mirror."

Floyd,
For years it was my understanding that Zambuto mirrors were only sold to four telescope manufacturers, Mag 1 Instruments, Starmaster, Teleport, and Starsplitter. Is Carl now selling to ATMs or the public?
Stu
Posted 02/10/2005 01:58AM #2
Here is a handy dandy comparison of a 10" Newtonian mirror performance with wavefront errors varying from 1/2 wave to 1/20 wave.

Pick your poison.

Roland Christen

Attached Image:

RolandC's attachment for post 88085
Posted 02/10/2005 12:34PM #3
>>>If you cannot afford the premier scope, then you must choose the best that your money will buy....

If you can not afford a Porsche, you drive a Volkswagen! They are both fine cars, right?
-----

Floyd et. al.:

Some random thoughts:

I am in a position to afford most any scope I want, no credit cards, cash on the barrel head. In fact, I choose scopes that are modest economically and yet satisfying. As in many hobbies, money spent on astro-equipment is often equated with committment and skill as an observer.

I believe this hobby is about getting out there under the night sky and enjoying viewing its many treasures. To me, it is not whether I have a GSO mirror or a Mike Spooner mirror that is important, rather it is the skills you and/or I have developed. It is my experience that an experienced observer with simple equipment can see far more than someone who has spent some big money on name equipment but is of limited experience. Not only will the experienced observer be able to configure, collimate and handle the equipment with more better but will have ability simply to see stuff that someone with less eyepiece time cannot.

So, yes, this is an equipment forum, but somewhere I think we always need to remember that the end result here is not the equipment but rather the observing experience and the pleasure and enjoyment that each of gets.

So from my viewpoint, given the choice between a Porsche and a Volkswagen, I
would buy a basic Toyota or a Nissan. Both will do the things that a car is supposed to do better than either the Porsche or the Volkswagen, will last longer, give less trouble, be less expensive to operate, be more comfortable to drive and probably be safer to boot.

Actually, given the choice of cars, most often I choose a bicycle, far more satisfying way to get myself to work and back but that is a different story.

Jon Isaacs
Posted 02/10/2005 06:16PM | Edited 02/10/2005 09:30PM #4
The "Quality" of a telescope, or car, or any other product for that matter, is solely a matter of perception by the consumer. Some customers (yo Floyd, Hal smile ) have a different perception of "Quality" than others (Donnie, Rick).

Floyd said, "You can not expect the same quality of optics and construction from a scope that cost a fraction of the other scope. This is not being realistic."

With all due respect, Floyd, here's where you may be wrong! Recall that the Japanese did just the same thing in the auto market in the 1970s and 80s. They were able to sell cars with better quality for a lower price than the American auto manufacturers. At least the Japanese cars were PERCEIVED to have better quality than the American cars. Echoes of this big marketing coup of the Japanese still resound in Jon Isaac's preference for Toyotas and Nissans. smile

Some sellers are able to convince many customers that a product fulfills their perceptions of quality "well enough", and "We sell for less" is their slogan. You know who I'm talking about.
You have to believe that Wal-Mart has discovered the key to what customers perceive as acceptable quality! (Heaven forbid, but that is the state of the consumer in America today.)

So the key seems to be the consumers¡¦ perception of quality. So which way will the telescope market go? It has already to Wal-Mart, in a way. Witness the "mass-produced" Chinese telescopes. But they are cheaper and better than anything I could buy in the 1970s.

My most optimistic hopes for the telescope market lie in
- First, improved production processes at the Chinese (or some currently unknown low-cost manufacturer). Variations in optics will essentially vanish.
- Second, in the potential for technological improvements in materials for optics and electronic imaging.

What is certain is, that if telescope consumers keep demanding it, some day in the not too distant future, you will see a light weight portable telescope with a huge aperture for $100. The holographically printed optics in this thing will "see" much better than the best current hand-figured mirrors. It would view a wide field and easily switch to high magnification. With all the needed filters built in. Maybe even adaptive optics to correct for poor seeing! What a dream! But isn't that the way that technology is going? Then Floyd, and Hal, and Donnie, and Rick and Rick (me!) will all be satisfied! Nah - our perceptions of quality will change.

Rick Wiseman

8" Zhumell Dob
90mm f11 achro refractor
4-1/2 f4 rich field newt reflector