Image of the day

Captured by
Bruce Karbal

VDB 142 Elephant Trunk HOO

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

UO Orthos Overated?

Started by nycdutch, 10/05/2003 07:35AM
Posted 10/05/2003 07:35AM Opening Post
OK... subject line got your attention? Looking for opinions info here.

I'm finishing a scope and since I can't observe with it yet I'm obsessing about eyepieces. I am primarily interested in planetary observing and already have a couple of Orion Orthos which everyone seems to agree come from KK in Japan same as UO orthos. I was thinking of collecting the rest of the series if I could find them used since they seem to be parfocal. Then I checked out the April 96 S&T EP review -- the Orion orthos rated LAST for on axis detail (with TVs and Ultima rating the best).

So... are circle/UO/Antares/Orion orthos overated? They seem to be the darling of the message boards. Maybe the Orion Orthos came from somewhere else. Has anyone done a good comparison of UO Orthos and TVs and Ultimas? Oh, and while I'm at it: does anyone else want to weigh in on the HD orthos versus the regular ones?
Posted 10/05/2003 08:25AM #1
They are good for the money, you know, bang for the buck. Tak orthos are significantly better, IMO, but they cost more ($141 new) are 0.96" (need an adapter), and except for the 4mm and 2.8mm HI orthos, for some reason or another they don't get the respect they deserve on the used market, probably due just to sheer ignorance.
--
Mike
Posted 10/05/2003 05:45PM #2
That S&T review did state within the text that those Orion orthos were not up to the performance of ortho's in general. They also had a different body/barrel than the current UO offerings. At the time of the article, those Orions's were basically the only common ortho's in the US marketplace, except for Edmund's (who were pushing their RKE's instead). Ortho lens sets can be mfg with identical radii for economic reasons, but those are not up to the true Abbe in performance. Ron
Posted 10/05/2003 05:54PM #3
My 2 cents... the 12.5 Ortho is unique in having both a simple design and decent eye-relief (around 10mm). I can (just) use it with thin glasses. The 12.5 Ultima by comparison has about half the eye-relief; the Plossl is somewhere in between, but definitely less than the Ortho.

-- William
Posted 10/05/2003 08:01PM #4
I believe the UO orthos (circle T ones) are
made by Tani Optical. I am not sure if they are
associated with KK or related to the Orion orthos.

The UO orthos are the eyepieces I use most for planetary
viewing. I've got the 4, 5, 6, 7, 9, 12.5, and 18mm
and am quite happy with all of them. The field of
view is small, but if you are looking at a planet
with a drive, it does not matter much. I've done
lots of tests, and cannot see any difference on-axis
compared to the high-end Pentax and Zeiss orthos.
The high end orthos do have slightly better edge
sharpness, but again if you put the planet at the
center it doesn't matter. Certainly in terms of
price / value there is none better.