Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Which would you pick ?

Started by Larry Citro, 09/10/2004 01:13AM
Posted 09/10/2004 01:13AM | Edited 09/10/2004 01:15AM Opening Post
Hi,

There are two dream refractors for sale on Astromart I saw today. An AP 7" F7 for $32,000 and a TMB 9" F9 for $29,000. Given that price is not a problem (not true for me, but I can dream ) which of these two would you get ?

If I was single and did't have any additional responsibilities I would blow my bank accout and get the TMB just for the additional aperture. But others may want the AP. I would love to here which and why. Come on now we all can dream !


clear skies,

Larry Citro
Posted 09/10/2004 01:32AM #1
Posted 09/10/2004 02:18AM #2
I've looked through two AP 7" refractors, and they were awesome; but the price still seems a bit high to me. I suppose it would depend on your usual viewing conditions, mount, and [your]physical condition, as usual.

If you have excellent seeing frequently, either scope should suffice. If not, why waste your money? Do you image, or are you primarily visual? Are you well off enough to really consider purchasing either of these scopes? Do you spend enough hours at the eyepiece? Can I come over to your place to gather photons?

James Adams
Posted 09/10/2004 02:44AM #3
Hi Larry,

I think a lot of that price is in the short focal length of the 180, and the fact that very few of the 180's were made at all, and even fewer were the shorter f7 ratio.

So there is a performance issue, and the more slippery collector/rarity factor.

I can't remember off hand if TMB makes a 180f7 focal ratio scope, f9 yes. My guess is no.

The 9" f9 lens would be killer on a lot of objects, but would not be quite the same scope for imaging purposes. Focal ratio is king in the imaging world.

If money were no object, then I would get a 200mm f6 APO built !

David Simons

David Simons