Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

why not a "premium" SCT

Started by Larry Citro, 03/13/2004 04:21PM
Posted 03/13/2004 04:21PM Opening Post
hi all,

i have often wondered why Meade and Celestron havn't taken a marketing hint from the Russian mfgs of mak scopes and produce a "standard" and a "deluxe" version of their SCT optical tube assemblies.

A wish list:

- Carbon fiber tube
- low index of expansion mirrors to help with rapid cooling
- built in cooling fan with microfilters
- knife edge baffeling inside the tube
- standard dew shield with knife edge baffeling
- finder with illuminated crosshairs
- mirrors figured to a higher sthrel ratio
- mirrors with a smoother surface
- standard crayford focuser for fine focus
- a mirror locking system that work
- a higher level of QA with independent test reports with each OTA


Anyone think of anything more ?

I know this would double the cost of the OTAs but I believe there would be a market for them

Am I all wet or is this a good idea ?


clear skies,


Larry Citro
Posted 03/13/2004 04:28PM #1
It's not an SCT, but it's a CAT:

http://www.astro-physics.com/products/telescopes/10mak/10f146mak.htm

Looks expensive wink

Tom

Attached Image:

tomhole's attachment for post 77439
Posted 03/13/2004 04:36PM #2
The market is plenty strong-enough as it is, so the question becomes one of *margin* -- not simply revenue. Based on the evidence we have (i.e. no such premium scopes from Meade or Celestron), I'm left with the assumption that neither company cares to push the fidelity envelope. The margins are far greater within the other realms (electronics, features, etc. which facilitate *use*).

Their production volumes would also nose-dive, further hampering margins and profits.

Best wishes.
-Dan
Posted 03/13/2004 05:56PM #3
"i have often wondered why Meade and Celestron havn't taken a marketing hint from the Russian mfgs of mak scopes and produce a "standard" and a "deluxe" version of their SCT optical tube assemblies."

This topic comes up regularly, and yes, there is room for impovement for Meade & Celestron SCT's, one thing that I hope that they never do is the introduction of carbon fiber tubing, given the insulating qualities of this material and the cooling problems associated with all sealed tube "cats" all that you will accomplish with this material is slowing the cooling process, terrible idea.

Thanks,
Vahe