This is a copy of a message sent to Rick about his latest article. I wanted all to share in it.
Rick,
Good article!
You bring up many good points and the comparisons are quite right.
The formula is enough to give me a headache, but that is OK.
The basic idea that a scope is a combination of its components is right on the money. Too much emphasis is placed on the primary alone I feel and to little is attributed to the other factors. For the most part, I have seen far too many people that feel "Good Enough" is fine. This is selling the scope short in my opinion. Too little effort is put into collimation and alignment of the optical train for instance. Misalingment and poor collimation degrades the image more than the quality of the mirror in some cases. The choice of components and even the elimination of scattered light with various techniques, flocking, and painting of surfaces and proper baffles or baffle like structures are overlooked. Every little improvement adds to the quality and many small improvements add up to one large improvement. The fine-tuning of a scope can be as productive as any money spent.
I would like to see an article written on this. Something that brings an understanding of how a great scope is actually made. I know that the best manufacturers are already aware of this, but I think that many ATM people are not.
Thanks again for taking the time to explain these complex issues.
Floyd
Rick,
Good article!
You bring up many good points and the comparisons are quite right.
The formula is enough to give me a headache, but that is OK.
The basic idea that a scope is a combination of its components is right on the money. Too much emphasis is placed on the primary alone I feel and to little is attributed to the other factors. For the most part, I have seen far too many people that feel "Good Enough" is fine. This is selling the scope short in my opinion. Too little effort is put into collimation and alignment of the optical train for instance. Misalingment and poor collimation degrades the image more than the quality of the mirror in some cases. The choice of components and even the elimination of scattered light with various techniques, flocking, and painting of surfaces and proper baffles or baffle like structures are overlooked. Every little improvement adds to the quality and many small improvements add up to one large improvement. The fine-tuning of a scope can be as productive as any money spent.
I would like to see an article written on this. Something that brings an understanding of how a great scope is actually made. I know that the best manufacturers are already aware of this, but I think that many ATM people are not.
Thanks again for taking the time to explain these complex issues.
Floyd
[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue
Amateur Imager