Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

William Optics 80mm scopes

Started by Inge_S, 01/19/2005 02:16PM
Posted 01/19/2005 02:16PM Opening Post
I haven't been active under this forum for quite a while, and possibly the William Optics refrators have been discussed. But I take the chance to raise this issue, hoping for quick feedback.
These refractors are now offered by a Norwegian dealer (at Norwegian prices), and four different models (looking much alike) come at four highly different prices.

I use the 80mm Megrez II (achromat) as a reference. Compared with this one, we have the following alternatives:

ZenithStar 80: 18% cheaper.
Megrez 80 II ED (triplet): 67% more expensive.
Megrez 80 APO: 270% more expensive.

I'm looking for a scope for viewing objects like the Hyades, Pleiades, M39 etc, and intend to use my other scope for high power work. I'm not really interested in a larger aperture. My immediate impression is that the standard Megrez II would be the right choice for such objects. Is the ED triplet worth the extra money. The APO is out of the question - I don't want an 80mm scope that costs me more than my 12.5-inch PB.

Inge S
Posted 01/19/2005 07:26PM #1
> Is the ED triplet worth the extra money.

That all depends on how tolerant you are to Chromatic Abberation (false color). Given the objects you intend to observe, CA isn't so much an issue. However, if you said high power and lunar/planetary work is what you want to do, I'd recommend the ED. My $.02.

Ken....
Posted 01/20/2005 12:45PM #2
Inge-

I purchased the Megrez II f6.25 Achromat, but along with many others I experienced some issues with the lens and had to send it back. Williams was great and we worked out a deal on the ED F7 triplet. I've used this Megrez II ED scope now for about 4 months and it's a fantastic scope for the price and well worth the difference between it and the Achro. I don't recommend going with the Megrez II f6.25, should you decide against the ED I'd go with the zenithstar. In the ED there is very little false color and the images are sharp and crisp. The scope is light, 5lbs and comes with a nice option for diagonal and carry bag. But if you don't plan on viewing planets at all, then the Zenithstar would be a fine choice. IF you plan to use high power on the clusters and maybe take a peek at the Moon/planets you'll enjoy the ED version more.
In my experience the Merope Nebula in front of the Pleiades is much easier to see in 80mm APO's then Achromats.

There is a Williams Optics Yahoo group;

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/William-Optics/

-Chris
Posted 01/21/2005 01:45PM | Edited 01/21/2005 01:48PM #3
I'd highly recommend the ED Triplet.

The initial sample I was sent was out of collimation, but David Yang was very good to work with, and the scope now shows good images. On the average night it will take 150x - 160x on saturn, and in excess of 200x on the moon before the image begins to break down. I also recently split Rigel at 80x, and suspect I could have gone lower, but lacked an appropriate eyepiece.

This photo might give you an idea of the color correction. Taken at prime focus with a Canon D60 while mounted on a gibralter.

No processing was done except for a crop and a 50% resize for esier web posting.

Tom T.



Attached Image:

tomt's attachment for post 87287