Image of the day

Captured by
Bruce Karbal

VDB 142 Elephant Trunk HOO

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Cheaper 2" Eyepieces?

Started by swsands, 11/08/2009 11:36PM
Posted 11/08/2009 11:36PM Opening Post
I am helping someone out whose father passed away. He inherited a StarMaster f/5.5 11" Hybrid telescope that is in excellent condition (now). However, there were only a couple of eyepieces and a 2" Big Barlow that were found with the equipment. The eyepieces are a 35mm Panoptic and a 12mm Type 4 Nagler. He is interested in learning how to use the telescope, but I think he may need a couple more to round things out. What's out there that doesn't cost $300-700 in the 2" format that would be worth considering? He doesn't have a very large budget to work with. I used to own some very good Russell eyepieces that were an excellent value ($65-70), but his are mostly in the higher power end of things.

Any suggestions? Maybe with the Big Barlow, 12mm and 35mm he is okay for now? That basically gives him a 6mm, 12mm, 17.5mm and 35mm setup. Thank you for any input you may have!
Posted 11/09/2009 12:40AM #1
ny suggestions? Maybe with the Big Barlow, 12mm and 35mm he is okay for now? That basically gives him a 6mm, 12mm, 17.5mm and 35mm setup. Thank you for any input you may have!

He has the one 2 inch eyepiece he needs, the 35mm Panoptic. The rest can be 1.25 inch. The 6mm gives him 256x, enough for most nights. The only serious gap is between the 6mm and the 12mm, he really needs something in that range, an 8 or 9mm eyepiece would fill that gap nicely and provide something like 170x to 192x...

I know of two eyepieces that are quite reasonably priced that would do a nice job for your friend:

- BO/TMB Planetary eyepieces, available in both 8mm and 9mm, these are negative-positive eyepieces so they offer good edge correction in faster scopes, they good eye relief and a reasonable 60degree AFoV. Used they go for between $40 and $50.

- The Synta 9mm Widefield. These eyepieces are also Negative-Positive design and work nicely in a fast Newtonian. They have a significantly wider field of view, I drift-timed a couple of them and found that the effective AFoV was about 70.5 degrees, a reasonable match for the Naglers. They also have reasonable eye relief. They do show a slight brightness near the edge, not as much as the Orion Stratus eyepieces but it is there to be seen.

These are sold under a variety of names, the Orion Expanse is one name. Night Owl sells them and I believe they are under $40.

In my experience, these are the best performing short focala length budget eyepiecee, I have tried a few others but these are the ones I still have and use as backups to the 9mm and 7mm Naglers.

Jon
Posted 11/09/2009 12:44AM #2
Thats certainly a good starting set you have already.
I'm not sure you need to get anything else right now.

IIRC the 35 Panoptic does not work very well with
the 2" Big Barlow. The center of the view is OK, but
the edges will be dark. There is a "TeleVue Panoptic
Barlow Interface" lens you can get to correct the
situation for $65, but it makes for a big, heavy,
far-off axis bunch of stuff. Might have trouble
balancing the scope.
http://www.buytelescopes.com/Products/1082-TeleVue-panoptic-barlow-interface.aspx

The Big Barlow should be OK with the 12mm Nagler though.

You don't really need 2" eyepieces -- its easy enough to
get a 1.25" to 2" adapter, and then use 1.25" eyepieces
for focal lengths below about 30mm. That might be another
way to lower costs. An adapter might be $20 or so.

If his interests continues, I'd suggest getting some sort
of wide-field eyepieces around 25mm and 16mm. These
could be 1.25" or 2" size. I don't have a specific
model to suggest. I'd look through some catalogs /
websites like Orion and University Optics -- both have
many offerings in the under $200 range. Also
watch Astromart Classifieds for used stuff.
Some old classics like the TeleVue
24mm Wide Field and 16mm Nagler Type 2 sometimes
appear and would be in your price range. Also the
Meade 14mm UWA. Read some reviews, too.
Posted 11/09/2009 02:29PM #3
I think you're there, and with excellent equipment.
Steve
Posted 11/09/2009 10:50PM #4
Thank you, everyone, for your excellent input and dialog! You are correct in stating that I should not eliminate 1.25" oculars for this project. The scope has a 2" JMI focuser with the 1.25" adapter, so that is not a problem. Also, you are correct that I failed to realize that the 35mm Panoptic will not barlow well without the additional interface.

I am still mulling through all of the responses, but think I have a good handle on where to take this. I certainly appreciate all of the expertise and experience folks have on AM!! grin