Image of the day

Captured by
Arthur Hogan

Wizard Nebula

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Choose the EP

Started by ghacker, 04/23/2009 03:48AM
Posted 04/23/2009 03:48AM | Edited 04/23/2009 07:02AM Opening Post
Ok, you have a choice of the Orion Q70-38mm (@$100), an AT TitanII-35mm (@$140), or a Hyperion 31mm or 36mm (@$190). Which do you choose? I've read one review that covered the Q70 and a Titan 40mm. The Titan generally had a slight edge except the Q70 seemed to go a little "deeper". Anyone with some practical experience/observations on these?

Other facts that may,or may not, be pertinent. You already have a 35mm Pan and 26mm-T5 so don't go there. You'll use them primarily in a f/10 SCT and perhaps a f/7 refractor a couple times a year. The EP would be exposed to Cub Scouts (we're talking 7-11 yr. olds). You don't wear glasses but maybe you should at these low power views. You have a Paracorr and a focal reducer.
Posted 04/23/2009 02:06PM #1
For star parties at f/7 to f/10 I would wait for a used gso superview 30 or 42mm to come up for sale. You can get them for $50 or less and they work well enough for what you need them for. Check out Amart reviews for more info.
Posted 04/23/2009 03:36PM #2
Hi Dennis

You probably know more about it than me. I have a Q70-38mm. It gives very impressive view from a C102 F6.5 achromat. For some perceptual reason the huge eyelens gives the impression of being much wider than the published 70 degrees, though it is surely just an optical illusion or the manufacturer would claim a bigger AFOV spec. The eyepiece has really big lenses. It is not extremely heavy.

Though higher F-ratio scopes are supposed to be friendlier to 'inexpensive' eyepieces, my F-10 CPC-1100 is not as friendly to the Q70 as is the F6.5 achromat. It is not a bad view, but the least favorite eyepiece in the CPC-1100. The CPC-1100 appears well-aligned, and other (shorter) eyepieces work great.

The Q70 exposes more astigmatism in the CPC-1100. Dunno if it is astigmatism in my eye because of the big exit pupil. I didn't notice this as much in the F6.5 refractor, which has a BIGGER exit pupil.

Or perhaps it would be expected in the SCT nearing the max field of view of that design, and has little to do with the eyepiece. Have not had a chance to try something like a Pan 35 in the CPC-1100 to know if some other long eyepiece would perform better.

Since the TitanII is rumored to be a Paragon clone (possibly improved in some aspects), and since the TitanII is pretty light-weight compared to the others, I've been tempted to get a TitanII to see how it works out. But it may be 'safer money' from my perspective to go ahead and get a Pan35 and then if it shows astigmatism, I'll know it probably ain't gonna get any better .




Posted 04/23/2009 04:05PM #3
The Paragon is a nice line that is not top end price-wise. I let the ordinary public including kids view through my Pentax XWs. So far no disasters. I guess the reason is that with the long eye relief and comfortable cup for centering it really makes it easier for novices to "find the image."

These are waterproof eyepieces and the coatings are pretty strong, so I have to think that barring sand abrasion or something they could be cleaned up from thumb prints etc.

The main vulnerability I've noticed at star parties is a tendency for novices to try to stabilize themselves by grabbing on to the scope or mount. My rigs do look pretty sturdy but that is a much more serious source of potential damage to OTA, mount, tripod, etc., if someone grabs it as they start to fall.

regards
greg n

"Scope will get you through times of no money better than money will get you through times of no scope." --Freewheelin' Franklin
Posted 04/24/2009 02:20PM #4
There is a used 40mm Paragon that came up this AM on Amart. If it is still available you would likely be happy with it.
Posted 04/24/2009 06:15PM #5
Just to let responders know. I'm off to a Cub Scout campout so I can't monitor this thread until Sunday night. Thanks everyone for your input.