Image of the day

Captured by
james carter

North American Nebula NGC7000

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Eyepieces for 10"Dob

Started by davenmer, 04/08/2008 04:38AM
Posted 04/08/2008 04:38AM Opening Post
Hi all, I have searched and researched for some type of advise on what type of eyepieces I should get for my 10" f/4.7 Dob. I think i have decided on a 17mm Hyperion, but I am struggling with a low power EP. I have read numerous reviews, but most are using slower scopes and I hear alot about how the lower power EP's dont perform very well in the fast scopes...so there is my dilema. Basically, I want a wide field EP at low power for DSO's...and I dont think I can afford a Nagler yet. Looking in the $100 to $200 range, and something I will be satisfied with for a little while. I have never looked through a Nagler, so I am not spoiled yet, and don't know what I am missing. :S

David Alexander
Orion 10"Classic Dob
Posted 04/08/2008 06:05AM #1
Hi David,
At f/4.7 your scope is a bit demanding on longer focal length wide field EPs. I am not sure what ones I could recommend that you would be happy with at the price range you are wanting to spend. I will let others give their results with this search for a good mid priced long focal length EP. I had to resort to buying Naglers. wink

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 04/08/2008 02:29PM #2
David,

I am I am going to have to agree with Floyd on this. Even Naglers require a little help from a paracorr below F/5. You will have to make a choice between narrower fov like with a plossl, or live with degraded edge performance from lower priced wide fields. If you find something that performs like a Nagler for <$200, buy two and I'll take one off your hands. grin

DanL
Posted 04/08/2008 02:38PM | Edited 04/08/2008 02:40PM #3
Unfortunately, with fast scopes it really becomes apparent that "you get what you pay for".

If you can find one used for a good price, the 2 inch 30mm GSO Superview might be able to tie you over until you buy something good. I have one and use it all the time as a public star party eyepiece in a f/5.4 newtonian and while it has alot of seagulls, it still elicits "Wow!" responses from beginners if I show them something large, like M45 or M44. New I think they go for around $63 - if you can find one for $30-40, it might be worth it if you plan on doing public events - believe me, you do not want snot on your naglers!

Knight_Owl Services (GSO) Eyepiece Review

http://www.astromart.com/articles/article.asp?article_id=154

Other comments at

http://www.cloudynights.com/ubbthreads/showflat.php/Cat/0/Number/1199488/page/229/view/collapsed/sb/5/o/all/fpart/1

http://cs.astronomy.com/asycs/forums/p/17159/293857.aspx

http://excelsis.com/1.0/entry.php?sectionid=22&entryid=624

Can be bought new at

http://www.agenaastro.com/GSO-SV-30-mm-SuperView-Eyepiece-2-inch-p/e-gs-sv30.htm

The other option is to just save your beer & fast food money for a good used eyepiece like a nagler, panoptic, Pentax XL or a Vixen/Orion LVW.

K. Michael M.

David Alexander said:

Hi all, I have searched and researched for some type of advise on what type of eyepieces I should get for my 10" f/4.7 Dob. I think i have decided on a 17mm Hyperion, but I am struggling with a low power EP. I have read numerous reviews, but most are using slower scopes and I hear alot about how the lower power EP's dont perform very well in the fast scopes...so there is my dilema. Basically, I want a wide field EP at low power for DSO's...and I dont think I can afford a Nagler yet. Looking in the $100 to $200 range, and something I will be satisfied with for a little while. I have never looked through a Nagler, so I am not spoiled yet, and don't know what I am missing. :S
Posted 04/08/2008 02:39PM #4
A used 19mm panoptic or 27mm panoptic would be my choice. The 19's can be had for around $185 and 27's for as little as $250 used. The 27mm would be my preferred choice since it is more comfortable to use. Another possiblity would be a 30mm paragon (around $200 used). I use a William Optics 28mm UWAN that I picked up for $275 used. It gives 95% of the performance of a Nagler for half the price. I mostly use it in a 16" F4.5 dob. I do use a Badder coma corrector with it. At F 4.5 a coma corrector is a requirement for any widefield eyepiece 20mm or longer - even naglers.

Joplin
Posted 04/08/2008 02:58PM #5
What you have heard is true. Inexpensive wide field eyepieces don't perform very well in fast scopes. Many of them are actually very, very poor. If you can, try before you buy.

The 24mm Pan is a nice eyepiece and provides 68 degree view. It will work in fast scopes. Not as wide a field as a Nagler but very nice views just the same. Still, it will cost over $200 even for a used one. It will be about 50X in your scope and provide a 5mm exit pupil.

A run of the mill 26mm Plossl will give a slightly narrower view at 45X. A 32mm Plossl will give the same view as the 24 Pan but at much less magnification and a wider exit pupil. You can expect to see some bloating and astigmatism on stars at the edge of field in the Plossls when used in a fast scope. Low power yes, but not wide field.


good luck,
dan

Posted 04/09/2008 03:18AM #6
I thank you all for your time. That was the advise I was looking for. Until I can come up with the money for a nicer EP, I went ahead and purchased a 30mm GSO Superview to get me by for now. And I'm sure it will make me realize that when I buy a Pan or Nagler, it will be money well spent.

Thanks again everyone,
David

David Alexander
Orion 10"Classic Dob