Filter Shootout: M42

Started by Rod Kaufman, 12/12/2012 04:51AM
Posted 12/12/2012 04:51AM Opening Post
I've been trying to get in some eyepiece time for awhile now but the weather hasn't cooperated. I finally got several hours in on Monday evening in front of my home and that means suburban skies replete with Christmas lights augmenting the street lighting. So, I naturally popped open the filter cases and went to work. Limiting magnitude in my 16" F4.5 dob was roughly around 12 and I could pull in some of the brighter galaxies in Pegasus and Perseus. Skies were fairly transparent with a light breeze keeping the moisture and the dew out of the air but impacting the seeing a bit at 3/5. I could use my baader 9mm orthoscopic eyepiece to good advantage on Jupiter but the 5mm Zhumell planetary was a bit of a stretch. Floyd Blue and I concur that the badder 9mm ortho gave the best rendition of the ruddy colors on Jupiter in previous tests and I confirmed those findings again last night. I'm not sure if the baader genuine orthoscopic eyepiece is still available as I heard it was being discontinued but I highly recommend it and I was able to get one before the prices really shot up on it.
Since the great Orion nebula is a frequent target of visual observers/imagers, I thought I'd report on my experiences with various visual filters in my collection.
First, without any filters, the E and F stars in the trapezium were discernible in my 10mm Ethos and paracorr combination despite the ambient lighting and less than optimum position of the constellation. From the start, I continue to be impressed with the performance of the 1.25" Astrotech broadband filter. I previously reported its usefulness in observing some galaxies and I found I could barely continue to observe the E and F stars while observing more of the nebulosity despite ambient lighting. If Orion had been riding higher or if I were in a dark sky location such as the LAAS site in Lockwood Valley, I have no doubt the stars would be visible whereas competing filters kill the stars and that's usually taken to be a certainty with these types of filters. I felt the astrotech did as least as well as the Orion broadband filter in enhancing the nebulosity but still emitted more starlight. The downside of the astrotech filter? They've been unavailable or discontinued by vendors for almost a year now. Additionally, I'm not sure of the QC of these filters and some may be better than others. I doubt if they're individually inspected as a mass produced item.
The Zhumell ultra high contrast filter was quite respectable, running perhaps a bit behind the Orion model but is available at much less cost.
My favorite filter for viewing the nebulosity of the great Orion nebula has got to be the Lumicon O111 filter. In addition to enhancing the outlying regions, it turns the nebula into a milky white overflowing bowl in a 30mm widefield eyepiece. I find the latter to be quite breathtaking and I never tire of seeing it. The Zhumell and Orion(baader) O111s do well, too but I'd give the clear edge to the Lumicon.
Filter up! smile