Image of the day

Captured by
Bruce Karbal

VDB 142 Elephant Trunk HOO

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Initial Impressions: DGM NPB Filter

Started by Rod Kaufman, 07/18/2013 06:50AM
Posted 07/18/2013 06:50AM Opening Post
During new moon weekend at Pinos this July, I caught a view through a Discovery 12.5" equipped with a 20mm ES 100 AFOV eyepiece and an DGM NPB filter centered on the western segment of the Veil nebula. I was impressed by the fact that the view was not only outstanding but also by the fact that an 0111 filter is usually the optimum filter for this object. This piqued my interest and I ordered an NPB a few days ago and tested it tonight under challenging conditions in my 16" f4.5 dob. When I state challenging conditions I mean moderate light pollution in front of my home with a 3/4 full moon bearing down on my equipment.
I used three eyepieces and three filters in comparing various objects: an ES 24mm 82 AFOV, ES 14 and 9mm 100 AFOV and a lumicon 0111, Zhumell UHC and the NPB filter.
First, the crescent nebula: the fact that I could see it at all was impressive under the ambient conditions, better in the NPB in all eyepieces, similar in the lumicon 0111 and invisible in the Zhumell UHC.
The veil, eastern and western portions, best in the lumicon 0111 but still detected in the NPB and invisible in the UHC filter.
M27: The dumbbell is outstanding in the NPB, excellent in the 0111 and reasonable under the conditions in the UHC.
Dimmest object detected: NGC 6894, A 12.3 magnitude planetary in Cygnus, good in the NPB, better in the 0111 but not by much. The fact that I could see it at all, given the prevailing lighting, was remarkable to me.
Color rendition: I heard up at Pinos that the NPB has a red bandpass but the blue flash nebula retains its color as did two other blue green planetaries that I observed during the evening. I would rate the color fidelity and clarity of the images as excellent.
At this point, I'm delighted with this filter and I can't wait to see it perform under dark sky conditions...
Posted 08/01/2013 03:05AM #1
Now that the moon is not a glaring factor in the equation, I decided to compare the Lumincon 0111 filter and my DGM NBP on Tuesday evening in front of my home on 7-30-13.
With relatively good seeing and transparency, I could visualize the milky way coursing through Cygnus and down as far as Sagittarius. Not too bad for a moderately light polluted sky. Summer skies are ripe for filter comparos because they're mainly rich in prime targets: planetary nebula.
First up: Aquila:
1. NGC 6772--the dimmest of the observable lot in front of my home at magnitude 12.7. The Observer's Guide notes a UHC filter elongates the north to south annular disk while an 0111 filter further brightens and defines the annular disk. I chose this object because it pushed the envelope on the limits of detection in a moderately light polluted environment and because the Guide described distinct differences in appearance between the a narrow band pass filter and a line filter. In other words, we're basically talking Floyd Blue specs here by getting right into the wavelengths to systematically dissect the image in each filter. What could be greater than that? So, how did the filters do? To cut to the chase, the filters responded according to the aforementioned description of the Observer's Guide. Whereas my observations with the filters matched those contained in the Guide, I felt the DGM filter acted more like a hybrid between a UHC filter and an 0111 filter, providing ample enhancement of the image without excessive darkening of the field of view that typically accompanies a line filter like a Lumicon 0111 or equivalent. I think this becomes more important as apertures decrease in scopes utilized by amateurs.
2. NGC 7681: A large planetary, 11.4 magnitude, with the Guide noting a UHC filter increases the annularity. Both filters worked well here, with a nod to the DGM providing a UHC view without excessive darkening of the field of view. Very good through the Lumicon 0111 as well.
3. NGC 6804--A neat planetary at mag 12.0 that has a cometary appearance in the eyepiece. Essentially the same in either filter, with less darkening of the field of view in the DGM.
Cygnus:
1. NGC 6826--The Blinking Planetary--so-called because a central star appears to overwhelm the nebulosity when viewed head on but when using averted vision the nebula pops out again. The importance here is the blue green color which shows very well in the DGM filter but less so in the 0111.
2. NGC 7008-- The Fetus nebula: so-called because it resembles an in utero human fetus, shows a tinge of bluish green color in either filter, perhaps a bit brighter in the 0111 but too close to call.
3. NGC 7027--Noteworthy because of its blue color, bright at 8.4 magnitude, impressive in either filter, with an 0111 filter showing an outer shell according to the guide. I'll have to try for the fainter outer shell at Pinos.
NGC 7016--noteworthy for its blue-green color, quite evident in the DGM filter but visible in either filter.
4. NGC 6888--the Crescent nebula, previously commented upon in my initial post, now in somewhat darker skies and appearing more alike than dissimilar in both filters. I felt the views were quite good and I'll await the verdict from a dark sky location before passing judgment.
5. The Veil--better in my experience in the Lumicon 0111 filter than just about any other filter you care to name.
Next update, from dark skies...