Image of the day

Captured by
Bruce Karbal

VDB 142 Elephant Trunk HOO

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Need math help with binoviewer plz

Started by [email protected], 09/03/2008 02:46PM
Posted 09/03/2008 02:46PM Opening Post
Okay, my mind is spinning over the math here, and I'm hoping someone can help me out a bit. I have a 16" f/4.52 dob, with a Denk binoviwer. My problem is trying to figure out the magnifications of my eyepieces. I have the 2" OCS with the 1.2 Optical Cell. I have it all the way closed in the lowest position (in other words I did not unthread the OCS at all). I have a dual-arm power switch, yielding 1.2X, 1.8X, and 2.3X magnifications. My problem is that I also have a single-arm stacked in front of the dual, to give me an additional three magnifications per eyepiece. The single arm operates in 1.2X and 2.5X. So.....yeah, this is where I fuzz out. I've got three things going on: the Optical Cell of 1.2X (is this part of the equation anyway?); the dual-arm, and lastly the single arm.

I asked Russ for some help, and he said that the 1.2, 1.8, and 2.3 is what I get with the dual arm switch, but I don't know if he took into account the 1.2X OCS Optical Cell. And that leaves out the single arm in the equation.

I have a 24.5mm Meade SWA set, and if anyone can help me figure this out, I'd be very grateful. Essentially you'll have 6 magnification settings; 3 for the dual, 3 for the dual plus the single.

Thanks in advance,

Guy

16" f/4.52 ATM Truss Dob, Discovery Mirror
Denk II w/nags junkie

Posted 09/03/2008 05:41PM | Edited 09/03/2008 05:43PM #1
Okay, I've been looking at this in my free time today and I've figured this much out (sorry, I purchased some of this three years ago, and I had to put astronomy aside for the past two years, so I forgot some things): I have the 1.2X OCS, which gives my dual-arm 1.2/1.8/2.3X magnifications when the OCS is in the closed configuration, which it is.

I remember Russ saying that when you have to extend the OCS to achieve focus, you are increasing the magnification. With that in mind, does the 1/2" space the single-arm takes up increase magnification?

Now, if that's right, then the single-arm, if I was not using the dual, would yield 1.2X and 2.5X magnification. However, that figure on his website is using the 1.4X OCS optical cell; with the 1.2X cell, I should be getting 1.1X and 2.3X for the single-arm switch.

Here's where I'm still fuzzing: I should be taking the 1.2/1.8/and 2.3X and multiplying by 1.1 and 2.3 to get the two different ratios? That would mean, with the single-arm switch NOT engaged, I would still have 1.3X/2X/2.5X using the dual-arm.

With the single-arm engaged, I would have 3X/4.6X/5.8X magnifications.

To clarify, normally the dual gives 1.2/1.8 and 2.3X With the single arm attachment, those figures jump to 1.3/2/ and 2.5X and when the single arm is used, the second set of magnifications is 3/4.6/and 5.8X If that's so, then my calculations are way off for what I've been using.

Lastly, applying this data to my set of 24.5mm SWA's I get the following (16" f/4.52):
Dual-Arm only: 98X/150X/187X
Single-Arm only: 224X/347X/437X

The numbers seem to look what I'd imagine them to be, especially for the dual numbers. I know that the max setting on the dual is roughly what the lowest is on the combined view, I just didn't think the numbers went that high at 437X. It would explain why I hardly ever view at that setting though....

Please, someone give my numbers a check and see if I've made errors or not. Thanks!

Guy

16" f/4.52 ATM Truss Dob, Discovery Mirror
Denk II w/nags junkie