Image of the day

Captured by
james carter

North American Nebula NGC7000

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Pentax 30XW Versus 27 Panoptic

Started by jeffbennett, 01/14/2007 09:13PM
Posted 01/14/2007 09:13PM Opening Post
Hi,
I am currently using a 27 Panoptic, and am thinking of trying a Pentax 30 XW. Anyone have any feedback on how these compare?

I currently use XWs from 5mm to 14mm and like them a lot for both optical quality and ergonomics (good eye relief, nice eyecup). On the other hand, I couldn't deal with the field curvature in the 20XW, which is why I have used Panoptics in the longer focal lengths.

Scopes are a 10 inch F6 dob (AstroSky) and an 80mm F7 refractor (Stellarvue NHNG).

Thanks,

Jeff Bennett
Posted 01/14/2007 09:55PM #1
The 30mm XW will have less pincushion and be very sharp with very good coatings.
I too sold my 20mm XW because of the field curvature, but the 30mm is much better and there does not appear to be any present. the 14mm has a bit too, but is better than the 20mm for sure.
Now, is it worth the cost of a change? Well, if you sell the 27mm the cost should be reasonable, but it will be more for the 30mm unless you find a great deal. Even used they are not cheap.

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 01/14/2007 10:16PM | Edited 01/14/2007 10:16PM #2
I have a 10" F6 AstroSky as well and I've used a 27mm panoptic quite a few times (owned one for a couple years then sold it to buy other stuff). The only reason I don't have one right now is that I mostly observe at higher powers with the dob and I've been using binoviewers a lot with it. Right now I just use one of those ubquitous 30mm 80 deg. eyepieces from china. The 27 pan is a pretty darn good eyepiece and it's also 1/2 pound lighter than the 30mm XW. You would probably need to add counterweight to the back of the dob for the 30mm XW to balance. I know my Astro Sky 10" has a full thickness mirror and still needs cooling fans, a 3.5 AH battery and several pounds of weights in the back just to get it balance with a 1lb eyepiece, Telrad, and Orion 9x50 RA finder.

Joplin