Set for Dob 10"

Started by vlahmapoutras, 03/18/2010 02:37PM
Posted 03/18/2010 02:37PM | Edited 03/18/2010 02:45PM Opening Post
Hello to every member of this forum.I am a member for less than a week and I am surprised at how many useful and high quality informations this forum offers.
I am also a newbie amateur astronomer,owner of a GSO Dob 254/1250mm(f/4.9) Deluxe.I ve read Nightwatch,Astronomy Hacks,Star Ware and I'm about to start the Backyard Astronomer's guide.And though a lot of my questions were answered in these books there is one that still can't figure out: which eyepieces to choose for the given telescope.
There is a huge variety of eyepieces available but I decided to go for premium ones.That considered I want you to propose a set of eyepieces(4 maximum) that can also be used with a TV 2x Barlow(better if all 4 can be combined with the Barlow).By the way,I don't wear glasses and think of buying the eyepieces used here in Astromart but spend less than 300$ per eyepiece.
I have something in mind but I want to have more opinions so that I can settle and choose.
Thanks all for their help.

Clear skies
Posted 03/18/2010 03:12PM #1
For 1.25" eyepieces, the TeleVue 24mm Panoptic and 9mm Nagler T6. With your TV Barlow, that also gives 12mm and 4.5mm. They have the additional benefit of being parfocal.

I got back into the hobby in 1984 using a Coulter 10.1" f/4.5 Odyssey Compact which had a 1.25" focuser. For years, I used the TeleVue equivalents of that time period: 24mm Wide Field and 9mm Nagler Type 1. They worked for virtually all scenarios.

If you have a 2" focuser, consider adding the 35mm Panoptic for extremely large objects, e.g. the Pleiades and Veil Nebula.

Now is a great time to buy new or used.
Posted 03/18/2010 05:19PM #2
Dimitrios Vlachos said:

Hello to every member of this forum.I am a member for less than a week and I am surprised at how many useful and high quality informations this forum offers.
I am also a newbie amateur astronomer,owner of a GSO Dob 254/1250mm(f/4.9) Deluxe.I ve read Nightwatch,Astronomy Hacks,Star Ware and I'm about to start the Backyard Astronomer's guide.And though a lot of my questions were answered in these books there is one that still can't figure out: which eyepieces to choose for the given telescope.
There is a huge variety of eyepieces available but I decided to go for premium ones.That considered I want you to propose a set of eyepieces(4 maximum) that can also be used with a TV 2x Barlow(better if all 4 can be combined with the Barlow).By the way,I don't wear glasses and think of buying the eyepieces used here in Astromart but spend less than 300$ per eyepiece.
I have something in mind but I want to have more opinions so that I can settle and choose.
Thanks all for their help.

Clear skies

Dimitrios: Welcome to Astromart... You have a wonderful scope in that 10 inch GSO, I have actually have quite a few scopes but I have had a lot of good times with my 10 inch GSO DOB.

Now as far as eyepieces... There are a lot of good eyepieces out there, I have quite a few myself, more than one set, one set is comprised of Naglers and Panoptics..Personally quite often I use a set that consists of some older TV Widefields plus TMP Planetaries for the shorter focal lengths... Worth considering a less expensive set for now.

But anyway, my suggestion would be something like this:

35mm Panoptic: A nice clean widefield view and the maximum exit pupil in a F/5 scope. Mine gets a lot of use.

16 mm Nagler: This roughly doubles the magnification but reduces the field of view, by only about 40%, I use this combination quite frequently even though I have similar eyepieces that fit in between.

9 mm Type 6 Nagler... Again, this is a nice step, I have 12mm Nagler but I mostly use it in larger scopes to provide ~180x.

7mm Type 6 Nagler... the 9mm and the 7mm plus a 2X barlow provide a nice combination for planetary viewing in a 10 inch F/5, particularly when used with a Paracorr.

So some point you may want to add a Paracorr to the mix... That will clean up the edges and increase the effective focal length of the scope...

As far as the barlow goes, well I have several but my favorite is the standard Celestron Shorty 2X barlow. I typically only use a barlow to achieve high magnifications when splitting tight double stars but it is my favorite. I would have to say it has been part of the optical train for just about every double under 1 arc-second I have ever split.

One of the advantages of the Celestron Shorty (and the Orion Shorty) is that the Barlow section can be unscrewed and since it uses the standard 28mm filter threads it can be screwed on the front of any 1.25 inch eyepiece and will provide about 1.5x.

So that's my 2 cents..

Jon

Posted 03/19/2010 01:57PM #3
Your getting plenty of advice here, most of it very good.

How you buy eyepieces is often as important as what you buy. Most of us don't get it just right the first time! So if you buy used premium eyepieces (such as TV's), you can generally sell them without losing much, mostly shipping and insurance. This allows you to change your mind. It keeps you from ordering 5 new eyepieces and then losing on the three you decide to trade later. And, it builds up some feedback ratings on Astromart, which is very helpful when you decide to sell something.
Posted 03/21/2010 09:08PM | Edited 03/21/2010 09:11PM #4
I've got a scope of just such a focal length, even known it's an 8, not 10 inch. Here's what I use most often and would recommend.

ep 1: 35 Pan OR 24 pan-for low power viewing of open clusters and scanning the sky. (second priority)

ep2: High quality 13-17mm range for medium power views and general deep sky observing such as a 13 or 12 Nagler or similar ***most important / used ep for deep sky for me.

ep 3-a good wide field (eg Nagler) in the 7-9mm range (just 1) for the deep sky objects that need more power (3rd priority)

ep 4-?: A series of TMB planetary eyepieces such as 4-3.5-2.5 for lunar, planets, and once and a while in deep sky. (4th priority)

At f/5, consider a Paracorr. The view is much improved. At f/5, the paracorr lives in my focuser.


Buying used on Astromart, you should easilly be able to get all of the following for under $1,000 with the core set of 3 eps for around $600. You also want to consider some things like weight. For example, the 24 pan, 13 and 7 T6 all weigh about the same and made a great set. I used those exclusively for quite a while before I got my 12 inch scope. Personally, I didn't care for the barlowed view with the T6 Naglers, but that's me. ymmv grin
Posted 03/25/2010 06:38PM #5
My most-used eyepiece in my 10" f4.7 Dob is my Nagler Type 4 12mm, followed closely by my other type 4's: 17 and 22. You might want to look at Pentax XWs as well. I have the 7 and the 10 - both excellent although I use these more often in my refractor.

In terms of bang-for-the-buck, consider the William Optics UWAN 28MM for wide-field viewing. It compares very favorably to the Nagler 31 and it costs a whole lot less. I've seen them used for well under $300.