Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Wide Field Choices

Started by jameslbrown, 02/11/2011 10:12PM
Posted 02/11/2011 10:12PM | Edited 02/12/2011 02:06AM Opening Post
Hi all:

I'm in the process of re-building my 12.5" f5 Dob. With the Televue sale going on, I'm thinking of buying a new top-shelf premium wide field eyepiece. Something that provides a field of view greater than 1 degree with an exit pupil of about 6 mm or less.

The primary candidates are the Televue Panoptic 35, Nagler Type V 31 and Ethos 21. If you think I am missing any worthy contenders let me know, but I would not go with Explore scientific even though I am sure they perform well.

Also, for any eyepiece, I doubt my eyes are young enough to use something that delivers a full 7mm exit pupil.

My technical goal is to have the best wide angle view possible in a 12.5" dob. I have a paracorr. My non-technical goal is comfort. I need the eyepiece to be user friendly. I hate kidney beans and such, and more importantly I rapidly lose my family's interest if the exit pupil is tough to locate (e.g. super long eye relief) or the eyepiece is otherwise hard to use. No one in my family wears glasses.

I've attached a spreadsheet showing cost, magnification, eye relief, exit pupil and true field for these eyepieces compared to the Pan 24 that I already own.

Lots of you must have f5 Dobs. Which would you pick?

Thanks for your thoughts!

Jim

p.s. I've been bino-viewing with my refractor and a set of Panoptic 24 mm's for the past few seasons and I love them. But to properly couple the light cone of the f5 dob to the binos I will be using a 1.7x Baader Newtonian Glaspath Compensator. I expect to use the binos a lot for medium and higher power. It is difficult to do extreme low power viewing with an f5 light cone and binos without vignetting though.

Attached Image:

jameslbrown's attachment for post 52822
Posted 02/11/2011 10:45PM | Edited 02/11/2011 10:47PM #1
If budget allows you'll love the view in the 21mm Ethos. I've put off buying "mine" because I have the 20mm T2. However, having acquired the 6mm and 8mm models, my ability to control my desire is weakening by the hour.....especially given the sale prices!!!

If you buy it, it will be used! 8)

-Gary
    There is only one constant in our infinite universe; it is change.
    D&G 8” f/15, AP178 f/9, C11, C8, ED80, TV-85, TV101&102, SW120ED, 6"Cave f/8, Solarmax 40, ES127MC,
    DM-6, Losmandy Titan 50 GEQ, G11, AP800, ES Twilight-1, UA Unistar Deluxe, WO EZ-Touch, 
    Denk BVs, 7x50 Fujinons, 10x50 Nikons, 15x70 Astrophysics, 16x70 Fujinons, 22x100 Oberwerks, 
    Sim Picheloup CPT, Canon 40D, 60Da, Vixen Polarie, SXV-H9, DMK 41AU02, DBK 21AU618, 
    Shelyak Lhires Lite Spectroscope, Rainbow Optics Spectroscope, Field Tested Systems RSPEC,
    Chairman, Southwest Region of the Astronomical League (SWRAL)
    President Emeritus, Historian, AL Awards Coordinator, Texas Astronomical Society of Dallas (TAS)
    Member/Volunteer, 3RR Comanche Springs Astronomy Campus (CSAC)
    ALCOR, Advisor to the Board, Texas Star Party (TSP)
    NASA-JPL Solar System Ambassador Volunteer (SSA)
Posted 02/12/2011 12:13AM #2
When I owned a Nagler 31, it received many compliments in all the scopes I placed it in. 1.3 degrees is pretty impressive and you can save some bucks over the Ethos (also very nice).

George
Posted 02/12/2011 02:03AM #3
Jim:

I have a couple of F/5 Dobs (10 and 25) plus a 12.5 inch F/4.06 and a 16 inch F/4.42. I have both the 31mm Nagler and the 35mm Panoptic. I do not have experience with the Ethos. I use a Paracorr all the time.

The 31mm Nagler is just a supreme eyepiece, the views are just so nice and clean right up to the edge, I play games watching clusters drift past the field stop. It is a rare night when I use the 35mm Panoptic, the only reason is remind myself that it too is a pretty darn good eyepiece... I think you have two choices, the 31mm Nagler and the 21mm Ethos. You can use the 31mm Nagler without the Paracorr and get about 1.5 degrees TFoV, my F/4.06 gives me 1.6 degrees + with a Paracorr...

Jon