Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Help: Mk67 or Celestron 8" SCT?

Started by toml, 07/29/2003 04:44AM
Posted 07/29/2003 04:44AM Opening Post
I have a Nexstar 8 that I got for cheap. I haven't been thrilled with the N8 OTA, nor have I done anything to try to make it less 'soft' (I believe it's in pretty okay collimation, but have more to learn in that dept. too). Anyway, I have a 8" dob, which has good optics, better than the N8 I believe. But a dob on planets isn't super cool. Not only the pushing constantly at high power, but also the spikes get pretty big, and finally the f6 isn't made for high mag views is it? So I keep hearing everywhere that Intes Mak Casses are refractor like (really? even with such a large CO? is the CO smaller than a SCT which doesn't really have the best contrast now does it?) ...well is all this better in a MK67...I guess I don't care too much about light grasp, because let's face it 6 or 8 inches even isn't going to easily show spiral structure...but if it isn't better on planets, contrast detail, (ie, ease of spotting GRS) and ability to take MAGNIFICATION without going cottony, then it isn't a worthy purchase for me I think (why not just keep the 8" sct and trade the dob up to a 15" for a one two punch: one portable, the other a big gun). I'm thinking MK67 because it's the same weight/height as the 8" sct and could easily be adapted to my N8 goto/tracking mount which is fun in and of itself.

none of my 3 (dob, sct and mk67 on order) scopes are DSO monsters, but I just hope one of these 3 winds up being a planetary monster, then I can sell the other 2 (can you say aperture redundancy) to fund a DSO monster and have the best of all worlds....in theory...just please somebody tell me that the MK67 is going to kill on planets or at least be noticably better than the SCT8 (it's safe to say that here--provided it's true--as i think we're alone smile

advice?

Tom.

Posted 07/29/2003 07:16AM #1
I owned both a very good celestron 8 and a delux mk67 with .989 strehl ratio.

The celestron I thought was a killer on planets very sharpoptics startested to close on 1/8th wave. Slightly undercorrected but nice images.

The MK67 was at first disapointing me but when I collimated it and waited for the optics to cool it was something else.

Inky black bacground perfectly even diffraction rings compared to more indistinct diffraction patterns on the C-8 and greyish background.

I wound the intes up to 500 one night and was amazed on the moon the image was still nice. the obstruction was 53mm out of 152mm just under 35% the C-8 was 34%.

I feel one major advantage is the better corrector coatings on the intes v the celestron. Also baffling was clearly more effective.

Re the Mak mk67 it can't be denied it had the edge for planets and I was skeptical beforehand. On deep sky the C-8 was brighter and the extra resolution came to the fore especially on globulars.

So there you go the mak cass inch for inch was superb on planets. In saying this compared to a refractor the obstruction meant fatter stars ie more diffraction rings even with superb optics.
Posted 07/29/2003 09:52PM #2
Before selling that Nexstar8 please do learn more about collimating a sct.I use to own a Meade LX-6 which I thought had only ok optics.One night when seeing was very good (unusual in Cincinnati)I took the time to get collimation
spot on.Wow!Only then did I learn that LX-6 had great optics.-Vic