Center dotting a Primary, how close???

Started by jonisaacs, 07/10/2006 10:33PM
Posted 07/10/2006 10:33PM Opening Post
I have been pondering how accurately the center ring must be placed in order to accurately collimate using lasers and barlowed lasers.

Most often I seem to get very good results with my normal technique, an computer drawn circle with a center hole, cut out, center dot is then placed and the ring is place around the hole. Nice star tests in F/5 scopes.

However with the realization that the diffraction limited circle of an F4 scope is only 1.1mm, I am wondering if this means that dot needs to place with a high degree of accuracy, maybe 0.1 mm or even less??

I know one can collimate using a star test, probably the best way to go for sure, but I am doing this alone and moving from the eyepiece to the cell, finding the star, well it ain't all that easy.

Any thoughts, experiences, analysis would be appreciated.


Clear skies

jon
Posted 07/11/2006 12:22AM #1
If you use the computer drawn circle with a hole in it's center, that should be good enough for any mirror.
Jim Fly offers a great acetate sheet with the circles marked for various size mirrors and it has a place in the center where scotch tape is placed and small holes stick it to the circle or triangle marker and the backing is removed from the triangle or circle revealing the sticky side. When the acetate is placed over the mirror the center is pressed against the mirror and the circle or triagle is transfered and the scotch tape pulls free. Great system and not much money.

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 07/12/2006 12:05AM #2
Okay--so, here we are talking about how accurate the center of the dot has to be. I didn't follow the final results, maybe, but it was something like half a millimeter last I looked.

The spot on my laser collimator is at least a mm across--probably more. And, I actually don't spot it, I have a paper reinforcer with at least five or six mm across--

And, by the way, when I am looking at the dot illuminated by the laser--it is something like four or five feet away at least--

Okay, so here comes the question-- Just how closely can you measure the laser hitting the center dot with these conditions?

Alex